|
Speciality Spotlight
-
Vasama J-P, Linthicum FH Jr. (House Ear Inst,Los Angeles)
Menieres Disease and Endolymphatic Hydrops Without Menieres Symptoms:Temporal Bone Histopathology
Acta Otolaryngol (Stock) 119:297-301,1999
This is a good article from another authentic study of T.Bare Sections studied in 21 yrs. Wherein E.Hydrops is noted without any symptoms of Menieres .This study therefore is interesting in comparing histopathological finding in so-called normal EARS with those of of patients with Menieres Disease. Nevertheless it is an established fact that E. Hydrops is the most important pathological finding correlating Menieres disease patients.
-
Yazawa Y,Suzuki M,Kitano H,et al (Shiga Univ,Otsu , Japan)
Intraoperative Mitomycin C in Endolymphatic Sac Surgery for Menieres Disease : A pilot Study.
ORL J Otorhinolyngol Relat Spec 61:188-194,1999
The use of mitomycin C to prevent postoperative fibrosis is the basis in this sac surgery done in 14 patients who in 6 months follow-up has shown no vertigo ,10db improvement in hearing in 5 patients and reduction of tinnitus.
This may be of benefit in sac surgery provided long-term results are available .Long-term results of sac surgery without mitomycin show definitely unsatisfactory results hence use of mitomycin in sac surgery may prove long term results.
-
Yotsuyanagi T, Nihei Y, Yokoi K, et al (Hirosaki Univ, Japan)
Functional Reconstruction Using a Depressor Anguli Oris Musculocutaneous Flap for Large Lower Lip Defects, Especially for Elderly Patients.
Plast Reconstr Surg 103: 850-856, 1999
The most common lesion of the malignant lesions of oral cavity is lower lip squamous carcinoma
In planning the reconstruction of large excision defect the following factors should be kept in mind.
– Maintenance of sphineteric action
– Retention of sensation
– A large enough opening for the mouth
– Acceptable cosmetic appearance.
In surgical technique described – Nerve supply and Blood supply is well preserved.
-
Raulin C, Schroeter CA, Weiss RA, et al (Laserklinik, Karlsruhe, Germany; Med Centre, Maastricht, The Netherlands; Johns Hopkins Univ, Baltimore, Md; et al)
Treatment of Port-Wine Stains With a Noncoherent Pulsed Light Source: A Retrospective Study.
Arch Dermatol 135: 679-683, 1999
Thirty-seven patients with 40 port-wine stains between 1994 to 1997, aged 1 to 68 years were treated with intense pulsed light source (IPLS). Before and after treatment, photographs were taken. All side effects recorded. The treatment appears to be safe and effective.
-
Franceschi S, Levi F, La Vecchia C, et al (Centro di Riferimento Oncologico, Aviano, Italy; Registre Vaudois de Tumeurs, Lausanne, Switzerland; Instituto di Ricerche Farmacologiche “M Negri”, Milano, Italy; et al )
Comparison of the Effect of Smoking and Alcohol Drinking Between Oral and Pharyngeal Cancer
Int J Cancer 83: 1-4, 1999
The relationship of exposure to alcohol and tobacco is established. However, the separate and combined effects of alcohol and tobacco between oral and pharyngeal cancer were compared in case-control investigation.
274 patients with oral cancer and 364 with pharyngeal cancer, 1254 controls matched were studied.
Observation-Conclusion – Alcohol has a stronger effect on oral cancer than on pharyngeal cancer. This may help explain why oral cancer mortaility is rising in men from many developing countries after many years of declining.
-
Pritikin JB, Caldarelli DD, et al (Rusb-Presbyterian-St Luke’s Med Ctr, Chicago)
Endoscopic Ligation of the Internal Maxillary Artery for Treatment of Intractable Posterior Epistaxis
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 107: 85-91, 1998
Ten patients treated with ligation of internal maxillary artery branches, along with ligation of sphenopalatine artery in sphenopalatine fossa had success rate of 100%.
This is another approach and has minimal morbidity. Problem is only verified with small number of patients. Appears to be a promising method.
-
Cheng D, Iriarte GC (Kaiser Permanente, Downey, Calif)
The Paper Clip Nasal Dilator
Laryngoscope 108: 1247-1248, 1998.
A narrow nasal valve results in serve nasal obstruction.
Plastic coated nasal clip shaped and inserted in rounded end of nostril, kept for one month serves the purpose very well.
-
Shoseyov D, Bibi H, Shai P, et al (Hadassa Med School, Jerusalem, Israel; Brazilai Hosp, Ashkelon, Israel; SHIRAM Asaf Harofe Med Ctr, Zerifin, Israel; et al)
Treatment with Hypertonic Saline versus Normal Saline Nasal Wash of Pediatric Chronic Sinusitis.
J Allergy Clin Immunol 101: 602-605, 1998.
Thirty patients were studied randomly with double-blind study.
Instilling 1 -mL hypertonic saline (HS) 3 times daily for 1 month improves the clinical and radiological conditions of children with chronic sinusitis. This treatment is tolerable and inexpensive.
This is an interesting study supporting the use of HS. The exact mechanism is not known.
-
Waridel F, Monnier P, Agrifoglio A (Univ Hosp, Lausanne, Switzerland)
Evaluation of the Bone Resistance of the Sphenoid and Ethmoid Sinuses.
Laryngoscope 107: 1667-1670, 1997
This cadaveric study included 21 specimens. Resistance to breakage of these bony structures was determined critically by dynamometric assessment.
This anatomical study identified highly fragile sites which correlate with location of surgical complication of functional endoscopic sinus surgery.
R. A. Otto comments: This simple study attempts to quantify bony resistances. It differs from Stankiewicz and Kainz and Stammberger, have stated that the weakest area is the area around the anterior ethmoidal artery, in the region of anterior base skull.
-
Metson R, Gliklich RE (Haravard Med School)
Clinical Outcome of Endoscopic Surgery for Frontal Sinusitis
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 124: 1090-1096, 1998.
Clinical results of this procedure was evaluated in 87 patients over a period of 2 yrs.
To avoid surgical failures, authors now use bilateral drillout technique in all patients with frontal sinusitis after a Lynch procedure.
R..A Otto comments:Though the results appear promising, long term follow-up are needed to determine it as a procedure of choice.
-
Casiano RR, Livingston JA (Univ of Miami, Fla)
Endoscopic Lothrop Procedure: The University of Miami Experience.
Am J Rhinol 12: 335-339, 1998.
This 2 year study included 21 patients with persistent or recurrent frontal sinusistis. Lothrop procedure seeks to create a common frontal sinus ostium. Ostium patency rate of 75% was reported. This prospective study sought to pick up patients who will benefit from Endoscopic Lothrop procedure.
A 57% patency rate was noted in recurrent sinusitis patients in whom conventional endoscopic tecnhiques failed. The chances of ostium patency was improved by maintaining a common frontal ostium of greater than 8mm in the anterioposterior dimension and 16 mm in the lateral dimension by Lothrop technique.
Authors provide some useful information correlating ostia size and patency rates. The study is limited and has short-term follow-up – R.A. Otto.
-
Lawson W, Reino AJ (Moutn Sinai Med Ctr, New York)
Isolated Sphenoid Sinus Disease: An Analysis of 132 Cases.
Laryngoscope 107: 1590-1595, 1997.
Sphenoid sinus disease raises difficult diagnostic issues. To distinguish from primary to secondary sinusitis or even primary to malignant disease is difficult. The 22 year study retrospectively was reviewed and signs and symptoms and radiographic findings were analysed.
Headache was most common and visual disturbances being the next symptom.
The key to diagnosis of isolated sphenoid disease is CT, with adjunct MRI as indicated. Findings of bone expansion, thinning and remodelling indicated Mucoceles and benign tumours. Bone erosion is pointed to malignant disease. A signal void in the sinus cavity on MRI is a sign of fungal sinusitis.
Authors presented a CT algorithm to facilitate diagnosis and treatment selection.
-
Dolbie RA [Univ of Texas, San Antonio]
A review of Randomized Clinical Trials in Tinnitus
Laryngoscope 109: 1202-1211, 1999
Most patients with tinnitus have subjective cases associated with sensorineural hearing loss attributable to aging, noise exposure, head injury, and other causes. Many patients with tinnitus have no hearing loss at all.
None of these treatments provided replicable long-term relief of tinnitus compared with placebo. Nonspecific support and counseling may help, as do trycyclic antidepressants in patients with severe cases.
This author has done a very comprehensive study of the current state of the art in terms of randomized clinical trials regarding tinnitus. His study is quite appropriate and his conclusions quite relevant. As he mentions, non-specific supportive counseling helps, as do antidepressants in severe cases. I would add that behavioral listening seems to be the most important and useful method we have in dealing with these patients.
-
Veling MC, Windmill I, Bumpous JM [Univ of Louisville, Ky]
Sudden Hearing Loss as a Presenting Manifestation of Leukemia
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 120: 954-956, 1999
Sudden hearing loss is a rare initial manifestation of hematologic disorders. This report described a case in which sudden hearing loss was one of the presenting manifestations of leukemia.
Woman, 65, was seen with acute-onset back pain. She reported a 6-day history of tinnitus and a 1-day history of sudden-onset bilateral hearing loss. Physical examination revealed bilateral serous middle ear effusions with intact tympanic membranes and clear external auditory canals. Laboratory tests revealed a white blood cell count of 33,200. Results of a bone marrow aspirate were consistent with acute lymphocytic leukemia. Audiologic examination revealed bilateral
profound sensorineural hearing loss. The patient received induction chemotherapy, with leukocytosis resolution. Audiologic examination results demonstrated significant improvement. The patient was discharged and has remained in remission.
This case was unusual in that deafness was one of the presenting symptoms of leukemia.
Typically, leukemia will cause deafness during its terminal stages. Leukemia can be seen as a presenting symptom of sudden deafness. The pathology of such patients, as seen from studies in temporal bones, suggests an immediate infiltration of pathologic leukemic cells throughout the labyrinthine spaces, followed by secondary degeneration of the sensory end organs and their cellular components.
-
Heiland KE, Goode RL, Asai M, el al [ Stanford Univ, Calif; Ehime-Univ, Ehime
City, Japan; Universitasspital Zurich, Switzerland]
A Human Temporal Bone Study of Stapes Footplate Movement
Am J Otol 20 : 81-86, 1999
Below the level 0f 2.0 kHz, stapes vibration was primarily pistonlike. Above 2.0 kHz, Anterior-posterior rocking motion rose logarithmically with frequency. Near the 4.0 kHz level, rocking and pistonlike motion were almost equal.
Stapes footplate vibration was mostly pistonlike upto 2.0 kHz. The motion became more complex at higher frequencies because of a rise in anterior-posterior rocking motion. Hingelike motions were not seen. This information may be of use in the design of ossicular replacement prostheses that mimic or improve upon normal stapes vibration.
It is interesting that they identify similar findings in that there is pistonlike action, but with higher frequencies, a more complex rocking motion takes place. Such studies are of interest not only from a physiologic point of view but also for those who do surgery in this area to repair pathologic structures
-
Chauvin K Bratton C, Parkins C [Louisiana State Univ, New Orleans]
Healing large Tympanic Membrane Perforations Using hyaluronic Acid,
Basic Fibroblas Growth Factor, and Epidermal Growth Factor
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 121: 43-47, 1999
Although 88% of tympanic membrane perforations heal spontaneously, the remainder require expensive
tympanoplasty to avoid chronic problems. Use of epidermal growth factor [EGF] has improved nonsurgical closure rates
dramatically in guinea pigs.
Complete closure of the perforation occurred in all ears treated with HA and EGF There was no evidence of
cholesteatoma in any middle ear
It could be nice to see such a study done in higher types of animals such as cats or monkeys. Perforations in animals such as
guinea pigs have a remarkable propensity for self-healing.
-
Shea PF, Ge X, Shea JJ Jr [Univ of Tennessee, Memphis]
Stapedectomy for Far-advanced Otosclerosis
Am J Otol 20: 425-429, 1999, Pg.54
Stapedectomy is indicated for those patients with far-advanced otosclerosis even in the absence of air conduction [AC].
The negative Rinne test distinguished far-advanced otosclerosis from other types of hearing loss. Most patients with far-advanced otosclerosis benefited from stapedectomy.
These patients seem to be the most grateful because they are essentially deaf to begin with, but then achieve useful hearing.
-
Bajaj Y, Bais AS, Mukherjee B [Lady Hardinge Med College, Delhi, India; SSK Hosp, Delhi , India: Kalawati Saran Children’s Hosp, Delhi, India]
Tympanoplasty in Children : A Prospective Study
J Laryngol Otol 112 : 1147-1149, 1998, Pg.89
All children had a central perforation without cholesteatoma. Ears had to be dry for at least 6 weeks before surgery. Patients underwent type-I tympanoplasty with autograft temporalis fascia.
Surgery is least successful in children with large or bilateral perforations.
-
Golz A, Netzer A, Joachims HZ, et al [ Technion-Isreal Inst of Technology, Haifa; Westerman Research Associates Inc, Shrewsbury, NJ]
Ventilation Tubes and Persisting Tympanic Membrane Perforations
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 120: 524-527, 1999, Pg.90
Myringotomy with ventilation tube insertion is the most common pediatric otologic operation.
A perforation was considered permanent if it persisted for more than 1 year after spontaneous extrusion or removal of tubes.
Persistent perforations were also significantly more common among children under 5 years of age.
-
Eisenman DJ, Parisier SC [Lenox Hill Hosp, New York]
Meatoplasty : The cartilage of the Floor of the Ear Canal
Laryngoscope 109: 840-842, 1999
An adequate meatal opening is important in postoperative ear care.
The success of otologic procedures frequently depends on a adequate meatal opening, Excision of the cartilage of the
floor of the ear canal is an important part of successful meatoplasty.
It is important to have good meatus in order to allow self-cleansing of the enlarged canal or mastoid cavity.
-
Soultan Z, Wadowski S, Rao M, et al [State Univ of New York, Brooklyn]
Effect of Treating obstructive Sleep Apnea by Tonsillectomy and/or Adenoidectomy on Obesity in Children
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 153: 33-37, 1999, Pg. 195
Obese children with enlarged tonsils or adenoids can have obstructive sleep apnea, which may cause poor growth and a failure to thrive. Effects of obstructive sleep apnea in children are disturbed sleep and sleep deprivation with subsequent daytime hypersomnolence and decreased activities, Obesity may be caused by this decreased energy expenditure.
Increased gain in height, weight, and body mass index is associated with treating obstructive sleep apnea by tonsillectomy or adenoidectomy in most children, including the obese.
-
Fitzpatrick RE [Univ of California, San Diego]
Treatment of Inflamed Hypertrophic Scars Using Intralesional 6-FU
Dermatol Surg 25: 224 - 232, 1999, Pg 165.
Intralesional injections of 5-FU in a concentration of 50 mg/ml were administered in doses ranging from 2 to 50 mg.
Mixing 0.1 ml of Kenalog [Westwood Squib, Buffalo, NY] and 0.9 ml of 5-FU in the same syringe caused less pain and had greater efficacy.
It was rare for a scar to not respond favorably. Scars with the greatest response were typically red, the most inflamed, the most symptomatic, and most firmly indurated. The first signs of response were typically reduced pain and itching, followed by softening of the scar, then flattering and decreased redness. Hypertrophic scars were more responsive than keloids.
The use of intralesional injections alone or in combination with Kenalog with pulsed dye laser is safe and effective in the treatment and prevention of hypertrophic scars and some small, isolated keloids.
-
Feder HM, Jr. Gerber MA, Randolph MF, et al [ Univ of connecticut, Farmington; Univ of connecticut, Hartford; Danbury, conn; et al]
Once-daily therapy for Streptococcal Pharyngitis With Amoxicillin
Pediatrics 103: 47-51, 1999, Pg. 199
Patients with group A b-hemolytic streptococcal [GABHS] pharyngitis may be better able to comply with once-daily oral amoxicillin therapy than with treatment taken several times a day.
Once-daily amoxicillin treatment is as effective as penicillin V therapy given 3 times daily in the treatment of GABHS pharyngitis.
-
Henriksson G, Westrin KM, et al (Huddinge Univ Hosp, Sweden; Karolinska Hosp, Stockholm)
Recurrent Primary Pleomorphic Adenomas of Salivary Gland Origin: Intrasurgical Rupture, Histopathologic Features, and Pseudopodia.
Cancer 82: 617-620, 1998.
Retrospective study of 230 patients operated for benign salivary gland pleomorphic adenoma between 1974 to 1993 was done.
Occurrence of pseudopodia (fingerlike extensions) appears to be important risk factor for local recurrences. This explains the lower recurrence rate in patients undergoing radical surgery, than those patients with enucleation and limited excisional surgeries with so called normal parotid tissue surrounding the tumour mass. If pseudopodia are present then long-term follow-up (to detect and treat recurrence) is required.
The Authors reinforce the importance of appropriate surgical procedure because surgeon is not aware of presence of extensive pseudopodia at the time of surgery.
-
Goode RK, Auclair PL, et al (Armed Forces Inst of Pathology, Washington, DC: Natl Naval Dental Ctr, Washington, DC)
Mucoepidermoid Carcinoma of the Major Salivary Glands: Clinical and Histopathologic Analysis of 234 Cases with Evaluation of Grading Criteria.
Cancer 82: 1217-1224, 1998.
High, intermediate and low grades have been reported. One study denotes the presence of cystic component of less than 10% is considered as high grade.
In this study, 337 patients were analysed which included follow-up data. 84% were in parotid. 13% in submandibular gland and 3% in the sublingual gland. Four groups were formed Group I, survival free of disease. Group II, survival with local recurrence, Group III, survival with local metastases and Group IV, death of disease.
This study identifies prognostic factors. Outcome varied significantly according to site and grade of the tumour. Metastases from submandibular glands were more frequent. The treatment should be based on clinical stage of the disease and histopathologic guide. Even low grade tumours in submandibular gland needs aggressive treatment and close follow-up.
-
Laskawi R, Rodel R, et al (Univ of Gottingen, Germany)
Retrospective Analysis of 35 Patients with Acinic Cell Carcinoma of the Parotid Gland.
J OralMaxillofac Surg 56: 440-443, 1998.
This is a rare tumour, occurs in late middle age commonly in females. Retrospectively studied because of its rarity. The study included 35 patients treated between 1945 and 1994. Surgery is the therapy of choice. The response to radiation is not favourable either to prevent recurrences or increase in survival period. The latter part is of particular interest in management.
-
Yang CY, Andersen PE, et al (Oregon Health Sciences Univ, Portland)
Nodal Disease in Purely Glottic Carcinoma: Is Elective Neck Treatment Worthwhile?
Laryngoscope 108: 1006-1008, 1998.
All patients were included with glottic cancer between 1984 to 1994. Ninety-two patients were identified who had at least 2 yrs of follow-up for T stage, cord mobility, CT scan, nodal disease, lesion extension, treatment modality and tumour pathology. Recurrences were reviewed.
Occult nodal disease with NO glottic carcinoma was low with 0% incidence in T1 and T2 stage disease and 19% in T3 and T4 stage disease. Only paratracheal level II and III nodes were at high risk. Therefore, elective neck dissection should be performed for advanced disease in case with low morbidity. CT scanning was not useful for staging in these patients.
-
Asakage T, Yokose T, Mukai K, et al (Natl Cancer Ctr Hosp East, Chiba, Japan; Tohoku Univ, Miyagi, Japan)
Tumor Thickness Predicts Cervical Metastasis in Patients with State I/II Carcinoma of the Tongue.
Cancer 82: 1443-1448, 1998
The retrospective study included 44 patients with previously untreated stage I/II carcinoma of tongue involving the anterior two thirds of the tongues. They were treated by partial glossectomy only. Twenty-one patients had cervical metastasis and 23 were without. Tumour thickness and other variables were compared.
Tumour thickness more than 4mm thickness are at higher risk of cervical metastases and were regarded as having latent metastasis. Conservative supramyohyoid neck dissection, as performed for T1N1 or T2N1 carcinoma of the tongue may be suitable.
This article confirms depth of invasion in more predictive of cervical metastasis than T classification. Spiro et al suggested this even for 2mm thickness and more.
-
Cruz IB, Snijders PJF, Meijer CJ, et al (Univ Hosp Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam; Academic Centre for Dentistry, Amsterdam)
p53 Expression above the Basal Cell layer in Oral Mucosa is an Early Event of Malignant Transformation and Has Predictive Value for Developing Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma.
J Pathol 184: 360-368, 1998.
Majority of oral squamous cell carcinoma have mutations in the oncogene p53.
To determine the relationship, immunohistochemical staining was performed on 11 premalignant lesions in which carcinoma developed. Therefore, p53 expression appears on early event in the carcinogenesis of premalignant lesions.
This combined with histologic criteria of dysplasia is danger sign. If more continued studies demonstrate this, it will be of great value in the management of patients with dysplastic biopsy specimens.
-
Int J Radiat Zakotnik B, Smid L, Budihna M, et al (Inst of Oncology, Ljubljana, Slovenia: Univ Dept. of Otorhinolaryngology and Cervicofacial Surgery, Ljubljana, Slovenia)
Concomitant Radiotherapy with Mitomycin C and Bleomycin Compared with Radiotherapy Alone in Inoperable Head and Neck Cancer: Final Report.
Oncol Biol Phys 41: 1121-1127, 1998.
Sixty-four patients were randomly treated in 2 groups. One group received radiotherapy alone and other group received radiotherapy with concomitant above mentioned chemotherapy.
Other group receiving radiotherapy with concomitant chemotherapy had significantly higher complete remission, disease free survival and better survival rates.
-
C. Gaelyn Garrett, MD, and Robert H, Ossoff, DMD, MD From the Department of Otolaryngology, Vanderbilt Voice The Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America
Phonomicrosurgery II: Surgical Techniques
Volume 33, Number 5, October 2000, Pg. 1063-1070
Vocal fold stripping almost always results in the removal of normal epithelium and a significant portion of the superficial layer of the lamina propria [SLLP]. Frequently, the vocal fold heals with significant scarring within the lamina propria tethering the mucosal cover to the underlying vocal ligament. Vocal fold vibration is hampered.
In the treatment of benign nonneoplastic lesions, vocal fold stripping techniques should therefore be abandoned in favor of treatments that spare epithelial and mucosal tissue.
Newer microlaryngeal techniques attempt adequate excision of the lesion without removing surrounding normal tissue.
The CO2 laser causes tissue ablation to a depth of approximately 200 mm at optimal laser settings.
It has hemostatic properties for the microcirculation [vessels < 50mm], making it ideal for lesions such as palilloma that are highly vascular and involve the epithelium.
Unfortunately, laser energy causes thermal damage to surroundings normal tissue, including the epithelial layer and deeper portions of the lamina propria, unnecessarily increasing the risk for postoperative scarring.
Therefore, do not routinely use the laser for excision of benign nonneoplastic vocal fold lesions when sparing of the mucosal cover is indicated.
Surgical Approach
Phonomicrosurgical techniques have been developed to preserve as much as possible the cover-body vibration of the true vocal fold. These techniques have been described as microflap or mini-microflap approaches.
They take advantage of a natural surgical plane within the mostly avascular Superficial Layer of the Lamina Propria SLLP.
Clinical reviews have reported excellent results with the microflap technique. The goal of the dissection is to excise the lesion within the SLLP without injuring the overlying epithelium and underlying vocal ligament.
Postoperative Care
Patients are placed on strict voice rest for 1 to 2 weeks gradual resumption of voice use under the guidance of the surgeon and a speech and language pathologist. Most complaint patients can expect to achieve 90% or more of their premorbid voice by 3 months following surgery.
-
Forrest LA, Schuller DE, Karanfilov B, et al (Ohio State Univ, Columbus)
Update on Intraoperative Analysis of Mandibular Margins
Am J Otolaryngol 18: 396-399, 1997
In 61 patients with involvement of alvelous, the study of serial frozen section biopsy of the cancellous bone at the mandibular stump demonstrated 100% corelation, and thus the extent of resection of the mandibule could be decided accordingly.
This article provides some evidence of the effectiveness of this technique in assessing resection.
-
De Stefani E, Boffetta P, Oreggia F, et al (Registro Nacional de Cancer, Montevideo Uruguay; Inernatl Agency for Research on Cancer, Lyon, France; Academia Nacional de Medicina, Montevideo, Uruguay, et al).
Smoking Patterns and Cancer of the Oral Cavity and Pharynx: A Case-Control Study in Uruguay.
Oral Oncol, Eur J Cancer 34: 340-346, 1998.
Four hundred and twenty-five men with confirmed lesions and 427 hospitalized controls were studied.
Smoking black tobacco cigarettes seems significant in oral and pharyngeal carcinogenesis. Risk was decreased with filter use and cessation of smoking. Black tobacco contained high tobacco-specific nitrosamines. A high tar content was noted in hand-rolled cigarettes thus combination has more risk of oral cancer.
This interesting article can help physicians counseling their patients – particularly impact of tobacco type and use of filtered cigarettes.
-
Colletier PJ, Garden AS, Morrison WH, et al (Univ of Texas, Houston)
Postoperative Radiation for Squamous Cell Carcinoma Metastatic to Cervical Lymph Nodes from an Unknown Primary Site: Outcomes and Patterns of Failure.
Head Neck 20: 674-681, 1998.
Out of 136 patients with cervical metastasis from unknown primary sites, 39 patients underwent excisional biopsy and rest of them various types of neck dissection. All received radiotherapy subsequently. 58 months follow-up was done.
Excisional biopsy and radiotherapy offers excellent disease control and survival rates. Those with ECE (extracapsular extension) and multiple nodal involvement the results are not as good. Radiation should start within 3 to 4 weeks and should be of full required dose.
Excisional biopsy did not have any reduction in disease control or survival rates. However, it should not be an argument in all cases. Detrimental effects of ECE and multiple nodal involvement is confirmed by this study further. R.A. Otto.
-
Simon D, Koehrle J, Reiners C, et al (Heinrich-Heine-Univ, Dusseldorf, Germany; Unvi of Wurzburg, Germany; Univ of Essen, Germany)
Redifferentiation Therapy with Retinoids: Therapeutic Option for Advanced Follicular and Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma.
World J Surg 22: 569-574, 1998.
About 33% of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) show loss of differentiation during progression of disease and then become refractory to standard treatment.
Retinoid treatment (13-cis-retinoic acid) reduces tumour growth and reinduces iodide uptake suggesting that redifferentiation in cancerous growth in (DTC). This is not so in on anaplastic cancer.
A 65% response rate was shown among patients of advance DTC. Thyroglobulin levels always do not accompany this response. Therapy is well tolerated with few side effects. No conclusions as the survival rates have been drawn.
This study has offered a ray of hope in the management of advanced DTC patients and further studies may offer better hopes. R.A. Otto.
-
Gimm O, Ukkat J, Dralle H (Martin-Luther-Univ Halle-Wittenberg, Germany)
Determinative Factors of Biochemical Cure After Primary and Reoperative Surgery for Sporadic Medullary Thyroid Carcinoma.
World J Surg 22: 562-568, 1998.
Twenty-seven patients underwent total thyroidectomy and compartment based microdissection of nodes. Thirty-seven patients with continuously elevated serum calcitonin levels underwent 4-compartment lymphodectomy at reoperation.
The report of 100% normalizaiton in serum of calcitonin levels in node negative and pT1 patients is notable. Postoperative calcitonic level is powerful prognostic factor. However, it is not clear whether the patients who are biochemically cured have better outcome. By correlating tumour size with the presence and location of lymph node metastasis, this study provides useful guidelines for the extent of nodal dissection necessary at the time of primary operation of Medullary Thyroid Carcinoma. R.A. Otto.
-
Dralle H, Gimm O, Simon D, et al (Martin-Luther-Universitat Halle-Wittenberg, Germany; Heinrich-Heine Universitat, Dusseldorf, Germany; Gemeinschaftspraxis Innere Medizin-Endokrinologie, Heildelberg, Germany; et al)
Prophylactic Thyroidectomy in 75 Children and Adolescents with Hereditary Medullary Thyroid Carcinoma: German and Austrian Experience.
World J Surg 22: 744-751, 1998.
In 1993, the RET proto-oncogene was identified as responsible for hereditary medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), since then patients with MTC based genetic screening have achieved biochemical cure by undergoing prophylactic thyroidectomy which prevents MTC and lymph node metastasis from developing.
A major breakthrough in the diagnosis and treatment with identification of this genetic defect in thyroid tumours. Biochemical estimation of serum calcitonin to screen in no longer required.
These authors provide a sensible algorithm for management of these patients. The achievement in 96% patients of a biochemical cure is remarkable. Time will tell if biochemically curing these patients is superior. R.A. Otto.
-
Nilsson O, Lindeberg J, Zedenius J, et al (Karolinska Hosp, Stockholm; Lund Univ Hosp, Sweden; Uppsala Univ Hosp, Sweden)
Anaplastic Giant Cell Carcinoma of the Thyroid Gland: Treatment and Survival Over a 25-Year Period.
World J Surg 22: 725-730, 1998.
Between 1930 and 1970, 50% of patients with ATC died within 3 months mainly by suffocation from the local tumour growth. Now only one similar death has occurred since 1989. Local tumour control has been achieved with debulking and pre and post operative doxorubicin and hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy.
-
Patel PC, Pellitteri PK, Patel NM, et al (Penn State Geisinger Health System, Danville,Pa)
Use of a Rapid Intraoperative Parathyroid Hormone Assay in the Surgical Management of Parathyroid Disease.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 124: 559-562, 1998.
During parathyroid surgery patients underwent neck exploration and the parathyroid hormone assay is done by preremoval of parathyroids and postoperative, during operative procedure, thus guiding whether enough functioning of parathyroid tissue is received. If adenoma is suspected then preoperative 99mTc-sestamibi scanning was used to localize.
Thus combination of preoperative scanning and intraoperative parathyroid hormone assay can guide unilateral exploration of neck.
-
Dhingra JK, Zhang X, McMillan K, et al (Tufts Univ, Boston; Lahey Clinic Med Ctr, Burlington, Mass; Massachusetts Inst of Technology, Cambridge)
Diagnosis of Head and Neck Precancerous Lesions in an Animal Model Using Fluorescence Spectroscopy.
Laryngoscope 108: 471-475, 1998.
This animal experiment using laser induced fluorescence spectroscopy demonstrated the utility in the diagnosis of premalignant lesions like leukoplakia or erythroplakia and histologically as metaplasia and dysplasia.
If this technique could be used to enhance over clinical skills (60%-80% reliability) such a tool could be very useful. G.R. Holt.
-
Shaari CM, Farber D, Brandwein MS, et al (Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York; City Univ of New York)
Characterizing the Antigenic Profile of the Human Trachea: Implications for Tracheal Transplantation
Head Neck 20: 522-527, 1998.
This study of 10 human tracheal wall detects Class I (Human leukocyte Antigens A,B and C) and Class II (human leukocyte antigen DR) histocompatibility antigens.
Different areas of the trachea have greatly different antigenicity. Minor salivary glands in the wall are highly antigenic. Antigenicity of the perichondrium varies. Mucopolysaccharide matrix is nonantigenic but the chondrocytes have antigenic properties. These differences in antigenicity indicate that some tracheal grafts would be more immunogenic than others and therefore more prone to rejection.
This article forms an important foundation upon which tracheal transplantation is an exciting possibility, if all the hurdles are overcome. R.A. Otto.
-
London SD, Park SS, Gampper TJ, et al (Univ of Virginia, Charlottesville)
Hyperbaric Oxygen for the Management of Radionecrosis of Bone and Cartilage.
Laryngoscope 108: 1291-1296, 1998.
Sixteen patients included in this study suggests good results with HBO therapy for the management of radionecrosis of the head and neck. Subjective and objective outcomes improved greatly.
HBO therapy has become an important portion of the equation in the prevention and treatment of osteoradionecrosis and chondroradionecrosis.
-
Davison SP, Sherris DA, Meland NB (Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minn; Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, Ariz)
An Algorithm for Maxillectomy Defect Reconstruction.
Laryngoscope 108: 215-219, 1998
One hundred and eight patients over a period of 5 yrs underwent reconstruction of maxillary defects.
The majority can be best reconstructed with a prosthesis, obturator. The guidelines are :-
– First choose a technique that retains greatest residual hard palate without comprising growth excision.
– Second, position the resection in the socket of an extracted tooth, to preserve tooth adjacent to the defect.
– Third, consider a split thickness skin graft.
– Fourth, to avoid the influence with the obturator bulb, remove the inferior turbinate.
– Fifth, if possible, use a feasible preserve palatal disease free mucosa for tissue coverage.
Finally consider the removal of residual adynamic soft palate if 50% or more has to be resected. Preoperative planning of the surgical approach is crucial, and the authors offer an algorithm to assist in this process.
-
KJ Doyle, Y Sininger, A Starr (Univ of California, Irvine; House Ear Inst, Los Angeles)
Auditory Neuropathy in Childhood.
Laryngoscope 108: 1374-1377, 1998
Auditory neuropathy has the following clinical features: Hearing loss for pure tones, impaired word discrimination, abnormal auditory brain stem responses, and NORMAL outer hair cell function. The results of audiologic testing in 8 children with hearing deficits most likely caused by neuropathy of the eighth nerve were reported.
The assessments suggested that, though cochlear outer hair cell function was normal, the lesion was located at the eighth nerve.
-
JK Thiringer, MA Arriaga (Lackland Air Force Base, Texas; Pittsburgh Ear Associates, Pa)
Stapedectomy in Military Aircrew
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 118:9-14, 1998.
Stapedial surgery may pose a considerable risk for those in certain occupations e.g. military aircrews who challenge the function of the cochleovestibular system with each mission. Aircrew members who have had stapedectomies have been rejected for all flying duties by the Surgeon General of the Air Force. As additional clinical experience was gained, waivers for flight duty were granted on an individual basis. The aeromedical outcome for aircrew members who returned to flight duty after stapedectomy was reviewed.
Before aircrew members returned to flight duty, patients were subjected to centrifuge and altitude -chamber testing, electronystagmography, rotational chairs, and actual test flights. In the entire group studied, no episodes of sudden hearing loss or vestibulopathic conditions occurred.
-
JP Leonetti, T Origitano, et al (Loyola Univ, Maywood, III)
Intracranial Complications of Temporal Bone Osteoradionecrosis
Am J Otol 18:223-229, 1997
Osteoradionecrosis of the temporal bone may follow radiation to the brain, parotid gland, nasopharynx, or superior cervical area. Life-threatening intracranial complications may follow.
In 4 patients studied, complications observed were multiple brain abscesses, aneurysm of the internal carotid artery; a cholesteatoma of the external auditory canal with extensive destruction of the mastoid bone leading to thrombosis and meningitis of the sigmoid sinus; meningitis with a small epidural abscess over the middle fossa dura; and prolonged infection of the ear canal, middle ear, and mastoid resulting in fatal otitic meningitis. The 3 patients who underwent surgery (mastoid) survived requiring careful and regular follow-up.
-
PA Fagan, JP Sheehy, et al (St. Vincent’s Hosp, Sydney, Australia)
The Cerebellopontine Angle: Does the Translabyrinthine Approach Give Adequate Access?
Laryngoscope 108: 679-682, 1998
It was previously believed that the translabyrinthine approach provided inadequate access to the cerebellopontine angle. The authors after analyzing 33 patients undergoing translabyrinthine surgery and 13 undergoing the posterior fossa approach have concluded that the translabyrinthine approach enables superior visualization through a wider angle of surgical access with minimal cerebellar retraction.
-
HM Dunniway, DB Welling (Ohio State Univ, Columbus)
Intracranial Tumors Mimicking Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 118:429-436, 1998.
Benign positional vertigo may not always be benign, as indicated in this study where intracranial tumors were identified in five patients who presented as “benign paroxysmal vertigo.”
When patients of “benign paroxysmal vertigo” do not improve after particle repositioning manoeuver, further assessment is needed to rule out intracranial new growths.
-
RC O’Reilly, SB Kapadia, D.B. Kamerer (Univ of Pittsburgh, Pa)
Primary Extracranial Meningioma of the Temporal Bone.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 118:690-694, 1998.
Though meningiomas typically occur intracranially, they may rarely arise de novo in the temporal bone. Because of the invasive nature of this tumor, surgical resection is difficult, and postoperative surveillance is necessary.
-
AE-M Moussa, KA Abou-Elhmd (South Valley Univ, Sohag, Egypt)
Wegener’s Granulomatosis Presenting as Mastoiditis
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 107:560-563, 1998.
Wegener’s granulomatosis is an uncommon auto-immune disorder, which has a peak incidence in the fifth decade of life with a slight male predominance. Typically, nasal problems are the initial manifestation. Otologic symptoms are rare.
The authors report 2 cases of Wegener’s granulomatosis manifesting as mastoiditis (a fourteen-year-old girl and a 20-year-old woman).
-
Harti DM, P Aidan, O Brugiere, et al (Universite Paris VII)
Wegener’s Granulomatosis Presenting as a Recurrence of Chronic Otitis Media.
Am J Otolaryngol 19: 54-60, 1998.
This is a case report of Wegener’s Granulomatosis manifesting otitis media with facial palsy. Plasma antineutrophil cytoplasm antibodies were detected by means of immunofluorescence. After three weeks of immunosuppressive therapy, facial palsy disappeared, the ESR had normalized and the size of pulmonary nodules had decreased.
This case report highlights the need to bear in mind non-infectious causes of chronic otitis media with otorrhea.
-
R Indudharan, T Arni, KK Myint, et al (Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kelantan; Hosp Tengku Ampuan Afzan, Kuantan, Malaysia)
Lymphoblastic Lymphoma/Leukemia Presenting as Perichondritis of the Pinna.
J Laryngol Otol 112: 592-594, 1998
A patient treated for perichondritis of the pinna was eventually determined to have B-lineage lymphoblastic lymphoma evolving to a leukemic phase. There was no pre-existing immunodeficiency.
Though lymphoma is the second most common malignancy of the head and neck region, the pinna as the extranodal site of lymphoma, has been previously reported only once. Hence the need to broaden one’s diagnostic horizon when inflammatory lesions do not heal within a reasonable period.
-
G Venkatraman, DE Mattox (Univ of Maryland Baltimore)
External Auditory Canal Wall Cholesteatoma: A Complication of Ear Surgery.
Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 117 :293-297, 1997.
Large primary cholesteatomas of the external auditory canal are rare. Cases arising from previous surgery are even less common.
This article presents five cases of cholesteatomas arising from the floor of the external auditory canal after ear surgery. In all these patients, the cholesteatomas were extensive enough to require surgery. The authors postulate that a careful surgical technique would help prevent canal wall cholesteatoma.
-
E Gur, A Yeung, M Al-Azzawi, et al (Univ of Toronto)
The Excised Preauricular Sinus in 14 Years of Experience : Is There a Problem ?
Plast Reconstr Surg 102: 1405-1408, 1998.
A few of the patients having a congenital pre-auricular sinus suffer from recurrent infections. In such cases surgical excision of the sinus tracts is required. Recurrence is very likely if the tract is not excised completely.
The authors have reviewed 165 primary preauricular excision procedures in 146 patients over a period of 14 years.
The recurrence rate was higher (15.79%) in patients who had active infection during surgery than in patients who did not have active infection (8.22%). The recurrence rate was higher (16.7%) in patients who had surgical drainage of an abscess before the procedure, and 8.16% in those who did not.
Recurrence rates can be reduced by excising a piece of cartilage at the base of the tract and by demonstrating the sinus with dye injection and/or probing at the time of surgery.
-
Steven M Zeitels, MD
Phonomicrosurgery I : Principles and Equipment
The Origin and Development of Endoscopic Laryngeal Surgery
From the Department of Otology and Laryngology, Harvard Medical School; and the Division of Laryngology, Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Boston, Massachusetts
The Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America Volume 33, Number 5, October 2000, Pg. 1047-1062
PHONOMICROSURGERY-
Phonomicrosurgery is a means of maximally preserving the layered microstructure of the vocal fold, that is, the epithelium and lamina propria.
Tissue Dissection : Laser Versus Cold Instruments.
Unlike the laser, cold instruments provide tactile proprioception during delicate microdissection.
Infusion into the superficial lamina propria is often helpful, whether a laser or cold instruments are used.
Precise tangential dissection within the superficial lamina propria [i.e., subepithelial cyst dissection] is better accomplished with cold instruments.
Cold instruments facilitate maximal preservation of the layered microstructure [lamina propria and epithelium] of the vocal folds.
The CO2 laser is typically used for vocal fold surgery and enhances cold fd instruments when the pathologic condition is vascular or is too large.
The Rationales of Phonomicrosurgery.
Phonomicrosurgical procedures are designed to improve aerodynamic efficiency and vocal quality by creating a smooth vocal fold edge that is not excavated with overlying flexible epithelium.
There is a little difficulty in the growth and regeneration of normal epithelium, as occurs after a cordectomy that is left to heal secondarily.
The subepithelial infusion of saline ad epinephrine into the superficial lamina propria has further enhanced the precision of microlaryngoscopic vocal fold surgery with the use of both laser and cold instruments.
The author has used cold-instrument epithelial incision as a standard approach for the management of such pathologic conditions as cysts, epithelial atypia, and cancer.
During the last 4 years, this approach has been extended to the management of nodules, polyps, ectasias, and varices, so a subepithelial resection of these traumatic lesions has become standard.
Phonomicrosurgery has emerged as a physiologically based approach for benign and malignant disease.
-
T Hoshino, Y Ueda, H Mukohdaka, et al (Hamamatsu Univ, Japan)
Acute Granulomatous Myringitis
J Laryngol Otol 112: 150-153, 1998
Acute and chronic myringitis seem to be caused by two different entities.
Acute myringitis manifests the following – otalgia, a granulomatous bulge along the malleus, and no middle ear infection.
Chronic myringitis is characterized by erosion or thin granulation of the tympanic membrane – it can recur after debridement and cautery.
Granulomatous changes of the tympanic membrane are rare. This article describes five causes of acute granulomatous myringitis.
-
NH Blevins, BL Carter (Tufts-New England Med Ctr, Boston)
Clinical Forum: Routine Preoperative Imaging in Chronic Ear Surgery,
Am J Otol 19: 527-538, 1998.
Imaging studies, especially CT, can demonstrate the nature and extent of chronic otitis media, which may not be apparent on clinical findings per se. Such findings can affect operative treatment, especially in difficult and/or revision procedures. However, there is a view that routine radiography of the mastoid may suffice in being very helpful in most cases.
-
TS Karhuketo, HJ Puhakka (Tampere Univ, Findland)
Middle Ear Imaging Via the Eustachian Tube With a Superfine Fiberoptic Videomicroendoscope.
ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec. 60: 30-34, 1998.
With a fibreoptic videomicroendoscope inserted through the Eustachian tube, 56% of predetermined anatomical objects in the middle ear were visualized.
However, one may find obstructive sites or mucosal folds that may prevent a complete view of all the contents of the middle ear cleft.
-
RL Hebert II, GE King, JP Bent III (Med College of Georgia, Augusta)
Tympanostomy Tubes and Water Exposure: A Practical Model.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 124: 1118-1121, 1998.
Myringotomy with tympanostomy tube placement is one of the very common otolaryngologic procedures done nowadays.
Contrary to previous thinking, the authors have shown that entry of water into the middle ear is not promoted by showering, hair rinsing, or submersion of the head in clean tap water. The chances of water contamination increase by submersion in SOAPY water or swimming at a depth of more than 60 cms.
Many of the previously advised water precautions are unnecessary in patients with tympanostomy tubes.
-
Rath T, Millesi W, Lang S, et al (Univ of Vienna)
Mucosal Prelamination of a Radial Forearm Flap for Intraoral Reconstruction.
Eur J Plast Surg 21: 166-170, 1998.
In 5 patients the use of a distal radial forearm flap to which buccal mucosal grafts were meshed in reconstructing oral defects after radical resection of squamous cell carcinoma is described. It was safe, easy to use and successful. Although the time is needed between creation of the flap and its insertion, this time can be used to deliver preoperative radiation and chemotherapy.
-
Yotsuyanagi T, Yokoi K, et al (Hirosaki Univ, Japan)
A Supportive Technique Using a Splint to Obtain Definite Contour and Desirable Protrusion After Reconstruction of Microtia
Plast Reconstr Surg 101: 1051-1055, 1998
The use of thermoplastic splint is used in 17 patients directly to the newly constructed ear, to prevent deformity resulting from odema and scarring. Patients were monitored for 3 yrs. The splints were used after the first and second stage of costal cartilage grafting.
This technique is worth consideration. G.R. Holt.
-
Personelle J, de Souza Pinto EB, Ruiz RO (Sao Paulo, Brazil)
Injection of Vitamin A Acid, Vitamin E, and Vitamin C for Treatment of Tissue Necrosis.
Aesthetic Plast Surg 22: 58-64, 1998.
Experimental animals used were rats. Injection of ACE pool, composed of all-transretinoic acid, vitamin A, and vitamin E is useful for the treatment of necrosis after routine plastic surgery.
The antioxidants and their general health effects were used orally in selected patients to better prepare their tissue for surgery by G.R. Holt and found this regimen to be useful.
Well controlled clinical trial is needed – G.R. Holt.
-
Abou Chebel N, Beziat J-L, Torossian J-M (CHU Lyon-Nord, Cedex, France)
Le Lambeau Myo-Muqueux de Buccinateur Pedicule sur les Vaisseaux Faciaux: Interet Dans la Reconstruction du Plancher de la Cavite Buccale: A Propos de 10 Cas.
Ann Chir Plast Esthet 43: 252-257, 1998
Ten patients were given the flap. The musculomucous buccinator flap described provided excellent- functional and esthetic results in the repair of the floor of the mouth. Its flexibility ensures good tongue mobility. However, it requires extraction of the mandibular molars and also must have intact facial artery that can be raised with the flap. The Doppler could also be used to identify the course of the facial artery intraorally. The flap must be placed anterior to the parotid duct and opening. The patient must now chew if the flap crosses alveolar ridge. G.R. Holt.
-
Kuhn J, Toohill RJ, Ulualp SO, et al (Med College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee)
Pharyngeal Acid Reflux Events in Patients with Vocal Cord Nodules.
Laryngoscope 108: 1146-1149, 1998.
This study with controls demonstrated patients with vocal nodules were significantly more likely to experience pharyngeal acid reflux and pharyngeal episodes were more frequent. These finding suggests a contributory role for GEPR in pathogenesis of vocal cord nodules. Given this association, the vocal cord nodules in some patients should follow antireflux precautionary steps like elevating the head while sleeping and avoiding food 3 to 4 hrs before bedtime.
Barium swallow is a poor indicator of reflux. It should also use empirical therapy of reflux in patients without any cause for development of vocal nodules. G.R Holt.
-
Rosenbower TJ, Morris JA Jr, Eddy VA, et al (Vanderbilt Univ, NashvilleTenn)
The Long-term Complications of Percutaneous Dilatational Tracheostomy.
Am Surg 64: 82-87, 1998.
Out of 237 patients admitted in trauma centre, 95 patients underwent percutaneous tracheostomy. Fifty-five patients were available for final follow-up.
The long-term complication rate of PDT is comparable to that of open tracheostomy. It is rapid, safe, easy, cost effective and is useful in patients requiring prolonged ventilatory support.
-
Ebraheim NA, Lu J, Skie M, et al (Med College of Ohio, Toledo)
Vulnerability of the Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve in the Anterior Approach to the Lower Cervical Spine.
Spine 22: 2664-2667, 1997.
This is cadaveric study. Anatomy demonstrated suggest danger of injury to recurrent laryngeal nerve more on right side because the nerve courses outside esophagotracheal groove and runs in oblique direction relative to the sagittal plane. Inferior thyroid vessel should be ligated as laterally as possible and the retractor should be blunt tipped to retract the longus colli muscle to provide intermittent retraction of the midline structures.
This article highlights the rationale of using left sided approach to the spine when possible. If right sided approach is used then above precautions are necessary to prevent injury to recurrent laryngeal nerve.
-
Postma GN, Shockley WW (Naval Med Ctr, Portsmouth, Va; Univ of North Carolina, Chapel Hill)
Transient Vocal Fold Immobility
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 107: 236-240, 1998
Common causes of adult vocal fold immobility (VFI) include, thyroid surgery, nonlaryngeal malignancy and viral insult. The 3 patients had acute VFI, an unusual condition.
This VFI lasts for 4 weeks or less. Anything lasting more than 12 months is called permanent. A variety of causes of transient and temporary VFI, have been identified: metabolic, traumatic, infectious or inflammatory, autoimmune, CNS, mechanical and neoplastic. Some cases are idiopathic.
This is nice article about the temporal differences between transient, temporary and permanent vocal fold immobility. These are to be identified before any therapy is undertaken.
-
Filler RM, Forte V, Chait P (Univ of Toronto; Hosp for Sick Children, Toronto)
Tracheobronchial Stenting for the Treatment of Airway Obstruction
J Pediatr Surg 33: 304-311, 1998
A balloon expandable stent, the Palmaz stent, was inserted into 16 children with a variety of major airway obstructions. Thirty stents were inserted in 24 separate procedures during the 5 yrs.
Results showed they are extremely useful in the treatment of neonates and infants with localized tracheomalacia and bronchomalacia in those with airway obstruction caused by surgery for congenital tracheal stenosis, in patients with incurable congenital heart disease. The stents can be inserted easily and can be left for long periods if necessary.
More clinical studies need to be performed using improved stent designs, to optimize the results – G.R. Holt.
-
Yumoto E, Sanuki T, Hyodo M, et al (Ehime Univ, Japan)
Three-Dimensional Endoscopic Mode for Observation of Laryngeal Structures by Helical Computed Tomography.
Laryngoscope 107: 1530-1537, 1997.
Helical scanning CT was used to produce high quality 3D endoscopic images of larynx. The method has been described. The method used was in 12 patients with normal and affected larynx, either by cancer, nerve palsy and atrophy. This method provided useful diagnositc and therapeutic information in patients with RLN palsy. In cancer patients axial images allowed better assessment of characteristic lesions than CT endoscopic images alone.
This new technology can take 3D data and through obstruction technique, produce an image than appears as the “New” of the larynx through an endoscope. G.R.Holt.
-
Riley RW, Powell NB, Guilleminault C, et al (Stanford Univ, Calif)
Obstructive Sleep Apnea Surgery: Risk Management and Complicaitons
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 117: 648-652, 1997.
Patients who undergo surgery for obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS) are at increased risk for postoperative airway obstruction, hypoxemia, hypertension and death.
In 182 patients with 210 surgeries for OSAS, the risk factors were identified and were overcome.
The use of fibre optic intubation can reduce intraoperative complications with OSAS who have large neck circumference and facial skeletal deficiency. Hypertension is a significant risk factor, and requires aggressive treatment. Nasal continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) prevents hypoxemia.
This article provides useful tips for the perioperative management of OSAS patients. R.A. Otto.
-
Osterlund A, Engstrand L (Univ Hosp, Uppsala, Sweden)
An Intracellular Sanctuary for Streptococcus Pyogenes in Human Tonsillar Epithelium: Studies of Asymptomatic Carriers and In Vitro Cultured Biopsies.
Acta Otolaryngol (Stockh) 117: 883-888, 1997.
Streptococcus pyogenes was found in epithelial cells for both symptomatic and asymptomatic patients. This intracellular reservoirs could serve as the source for reinfection. Perhaps antibiotics with good intracellular penetration should be used.
This study provided the novel hypothesis that the inner harbor for S.pyogenes in the tonsils may be intracellular and therefore requires the antibiotics capable of penetrating and destroying this intracellular bacteria, thereby, completely eradicating the bacteria and the chances of reinfection or passing on the infection to others. G.R. Holt.
-
Ament PW, Paterson A (Latrobe Area Hosp, Penn)
Drug Interactions with the Nonsedating Antihistamines
Am Fam Physician 56: 223-230, 1997.
The nonsedating antihistamines – which include astemizole, fexofenadine, loratadine and terfenadine – are very commonly prescribed drugs.
Terfenadine and astemizole cause serious adverse effects in interaction with macrolide antibiotics or the antifungal agents, quinine Such interaction appears to be less likely with fexofenadine and Loratadine.
To avoid an adverse effect (drug-drug interactions) one must avoid prescribing any medication that may influence cytochrome P450 system.
-
Iro H, Zenk J, Waldfahrer F, et al (Saarland Univ, Homburg, Germany; Univ of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Germany; Dr. Horst-Schmidt-Klinikum, Wiesbaden (EII) Germany)
Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy of Parotid Stones: Results of a Prospective Clinical Trial.
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 197: 860-864, 1998.
A total of 76 patients ranging form 2 to 80 yrs were treated. These patients were treated with routine treatment of sialogogues, bougienage, gland massage etc. with no resolution.
This effective treatment gives reliable long-term results. With this treatment, parotidectomy and its accompanying complications can be avoided.
-
Marvez-Vals EG, Ernst AA, Gray J, et a (Louisiana State Univ, New Orleans; Vanderbilt Univ Med Ctr, Nashville, Tenn)
The role of Betamethasone in the Treatment of Acute Exudative Pharyngitis.
Acad Emerg Med 5: 567-572, 1998.
The double-blind clinical trial was performed over 3 months. Forty-six patients were randomized to placebo and 46 to Betamethasone.
Betamethasone, used as an adjunct to antibiotic therapy reduces the time to pain relief. Most effective in patients with streptococal positive.
-
Naumann M. Zellner M, Tokya KV, et al (Bayerische Julius -Maximilians Universitat, Wurzburg, Germany)
Treatment of Gustatory Sweating with Botulinum Toxin.
Ann Neurol 42: 973-975, 1997.
Gustatory sweating (Frey’s syndrome) has been treated with scopolamine or aluminum hydrochloride and tympanic nerve destruction.
Intracutaneous injections of botulinum toxin (BTX) type A are more effective. Forty-five patients were treated. 50% patients reported complete relief and 50% showed substantial improvement.
This is safe and effective method. Long-term follow up is needed. G.R. Holt.
-
Adair-Bischoff CE, Sauve RS (Univ of Calgary, Alberta, Canada)
Environment Tobacco Smoke and Middle Ear Disease in Preschool-Age Children.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 152: 127-133, 1998
Six hundred and twenty-five eligible children for this study were reviewed.
Conclusions: Exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) during the first 3yrs of life significantly increased the risk of middle ear diseases (MED) in these first-grade children. Greater exposure to (ETS) had greater risk for MED.
Avoding ETS during the first 3 years of life could have significant impact on MED and its associated morbidities.
-
Berrylin J Ferguson (Divn. Of Sino-nasal Disorders and Allergy, Dept. of Otolaryngology, Univ. of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pennsylvania)
Mucormycosis of the Nose and Paranasal Sinuses
Otolaryngo Clinics of North America, Vol.33(2), April 2000; 349-365
It is uncommon and rarely affects healthy host. But for the afflicted patient, the speed with which it progresses and leads to the death, warrants immediate diagnosis and emergency treatment. It can be seen in diabetics and other immunocompromised patients. It starts in sinonasal region but rapidly progresses to rhinocerebral region and orbit producing proptosis and ophthalmoplegia.
Aetiopathology
It is a term used to refer to fungal infections of the order Mucorales which belongs to the class zygomycetes. These are termed as zygomycosis. This would also incorporate the other order of the class Entomophthorales. This latter is a tropical granulomatous infection of the subcutaneous tissues and paranasal sinuses by Basidiobolus and Delacroixia, which responds to local care in contrast to the order of mucorales.
Most pathogenic species are members of the family. Mucoraceae, Rhizopus, Oryzae is the predominant pathogen and accounts for 60% of all forms of mucormycosis and 90% of rhinocerebral cases of mucormycosis. Apohysomyces elegans is the most recently recognised agent and caused mucormycosis in an immunocompetent individuals.
Diabetics in ketoacidosis are disproportionately affected. Out of 26 patients with rhinocerebral mucormycosis, 70% were diabetic.
Other risk factors include neutropenia, systemic steroids, protein calorie nutrition, solid organ and bone marrow transplant, immunodeficiency, leukaemia, intravenous drug abusers who may inject spores of mucorales with their drugs and then present with space-occupying lesions of the central nervous system. The relative infrequency of mucormycosis in patients with AIDS probably reflects the ability of neutrophils to prevent growth of the fungus.
Signs and symptoms reported in patients within 72 hours of onset of Rhino-Orbital-Cerebral Mucormycosis.
¨ Fever
¨ Nasal ulceration or necrosis
¨ Periorbital or facial swelling
¨ Decreased vision
¨ Ophthalmoplegia
¨ Sinusitis
¨ Headache
¨ Facial pain
¨ Decrease in mental status
¨ Nasal discharge or stuffiness
¨ Corneal cellulitis
¨ Orbital cellulitis
¨ Proptosis
¨ Palatal or gingival necrosis
¨ Afferent pupillary defect
¨ CN VII palsy
¨ Periorbital pain
¨ Chemosis (without orbital cellulitis)
¨ Epistaxis
¨ Facial numbness
¨ Diplopia
¨ Facial necrosis
¨ Hemiplegia/stroke
¨ Malaise
¨ Ptosis (without ophthalmoplegia)
¨ Decreased hearing
¨ Toothache
¨ Earache.
Treatment
1) Reversal of cause of immunocompromisation
2) Systemic Antifungal Amphotericin B
Systemic amphotericin can be administered 1 to 1.5mg/kg per day intravenously by monitoring patients
3) Repeated and extensive surgical debridement
External techniques like external ethmoidecormy or Caldwell-Luc procedure, preferred to endoscopic
management
Orbital exenteration was advocated but is now controversial.
4) Topical application of amphotericin is 50mg vial and intravenous amphotericin B and 10mL of sterile
water. This can be nebulized with a Rhinoflow device into the nose. The dosage is 4 mL in each
nostril 2 to 6 times a day.
5) Hyperbaric oxygen can be used. It helps reverse the ischaemic acidotic conditions that perpetuates
fungal growth. Usually given at two atmospheres for 1 hr on a daily basis upto 30 treatments. It then
limits deformity by decreasing tissue of debridement.
-
Kenneth M Grundfast, Nicole Siparsky and Diana Chuong
Genetics and Molecular Biology of Deafness- Update
The Otolaryngologic Cl. Of North America, Vol.33(6), Dec. 2000,p.1367-1394
Incidence of acquired types of hearing impairment diminished, but a growing proportion of all childhood hearing impairment is seen.
Until recently only genes for HHI (Hereditary Hearing Impairment) were identified as syndromic causes. However in last 5 yrs many non-syndromic HHI were identified contributing to the HHI. Fifty-three loci have been identified for nonsyndromic HHI. Otolaryngologists, therefore, should have basic knowledge of HHI in order to diagnose, treat and prevent sensorineural hearing losses.
Currently 25% of hearing impairment are congenital. 50% of these are hereditary. 2/3rd of these hereditary are nonsyndromic and 1/3rd are syndromic.
Apart from monitoring of infants at risk by OAE (otoacoustic emissions) and auditory brainstem response (ABR), newborn screening should include genetic testing (GJB2) as well, but is prohibitively expensive.
Almost 50% of inherited deafness is caused by mutations in GJB2, which encodes connexin -26, a gap junction component on chromosome 13.
In such early detection, early interventional programmes give larger benefit to these infants and children.
Definition of Hearing loss vs Hearing Impairment
Hearing loss means hearing was lost at birth
Hearing Impairment means child was born with hearing impairment.
Deafness versus hearing Impairment
Deaf patient uses sign language primarily while hearing impaired patient uses speech as communication method.
Congenital Hearing Impairment (CHI) versus Hereditary Hearing Impairment (HHI)
CHI means deafness present at birth. It may be because of genetic mutation or pathologic process which occurs either during pregnancy or labour.
HHI is the result of genetic mutation. It can manifest at birth or develop later in life.
HHI present at birth is congenital hereditary hearing impairment, while HHI develops later is delayed onset hereditary hearing impairment. One of the most common types of HHI is autosomal dominant nonsyndromic delayed-onset of progressive hearing loss. Depending on the severity in the family, hearing loss will progress with the age. Several other family members affected helps it to differentiate this hereditary disorder from autoimmune inner ear disorder.
Syndromic versus Hereditary Hearing Impairment
The cause of a syndrome is either genetic or exogenous factors.
Genetic examples are Usher’s, Pendred’s, Waardenburg’s, branchio-oto-renal syndromes. Exogenous examples are gene mutation caused cytomegalovirus, rubella or Goldenhar’s syndromes.
It is important to remember that gene mutation can occur spontaneously so that a child affected may not have other relatives who are also affected.
Syndromic versus Genetic Disorder
It is important to note that syndromes which include hearing loss, may not manifest with it but can have other features. For example, Waardenburg’s syndrome only 17% have hearing loss. This is because of variability of gene expression.
SYNDROMES AND NONSYNDROMIC HEARING LOSS
There are 200 different syndromes with hearing impairment. Nearly, two-third is termed nonsyndromic which are associated with no other anomalies. Various modes of inheritance is seen in both viz autosomal recessive, autosomal dominant and X-linked transmission. Identification and location of many genes will further enhance understanding of this disorder.
Inheritance Patterns
Hereditary implies genetic basis of disorder. Three classical types being autosomal recessive, autosomal dominant or X-linked recessive. Though inheritance pattern varies in classical Mendelian patterns, the HHI is secondary to the interaction of several genes or the result of an interplay between genetic and environmental factors.
(a) Autosomal Recessive
Autosomal recessive comprises of 80% of hereditary deafness and the most common pattern. In the recessive transmission, the parents have normal or near normal hearing, inspite of possessing recessive gene. Typically there is a 25% chance that offspring might suffer. This is characterized by horizontal pattern. For offspring to exhibit, both parents must be carriers of the genetic disorder.
(b) Autosomal Dominant
Approximately 18% of cases. A vertical pattern of transmission. When one parent is a carrier, 50% of the offsprings suffer. If new mutation occurs in gene, it is inherited in dominant fashion. – thus offspring may be the first affected in the family.
(c) X-Linked Recessive
1% to 3% suffer. Genes located on X-chromosomes are involved. Affects males. This pattern of inheritance is similar to that of haemophilia, where mothers being the carriers but their male offspring are affected individuals.
Abnormalities in Mitochondrial DNA
This is another mode of inheritance of HHI. Maternal oocyte is the sole contributor of mitochondria. So any mitochondrial DNA mutation responsible for HHI in the mother will be transmitted to all of that mother’s offsprings. In some families, hearing loss may be the only mitochondrial disease.
Mitochondrial DNA encodes mitochondrial proteins, tRNA and rRNA. Mutation in tRNA and rRNA are associated with nonsyndromic hearing loss. Another suspect in mitochondrial HHI is a mitochondrial import protein deafness/dystonia peptide (DDP).
The expression of mitochondrial HHI varies greatly. Several other mitochondrial genes associated with nonsyndromic hearing loss and syndromic is already listed. Mutation in mitochondrial DNA encoding tRNA have been linked to HHI whereas mutation of Rrna is associated with susceptibility to aminoglycoside ototoxicity. DNA mutation mt3243 is associated with two syndromes (1) maternally inherited diabetes and deafness (MIDD) and (2) myopathy-encephalopathy-lactic acidosis stroke (MELAS).
PENETRANCE, EXPRESSIVITY, AND GENETIC HETEROGENEITY
The diagnosis of HHI inherited by autosomal recessive and autosomal dominant is not easy in some cases because of lack of manifestation of the features.
The penetrance is the terminology used to indicate manifest expression of a gene. It is all-or-none phenomenon. So there are penetrant and non-penetrant genes. The expressivity is used to indicate the degree to which a penetrant gene will cause expression of abnormal function.
Expression may be varied, even though the two individuals may possess the same gene. Recent research suggests that the sex of the parent from whom a gene mutation is inherited will influence the expression. This is termed as Genomic Imprinting.
Genetic heterogenicity implies that different mutations involving different genes can result in an identical or similar phenotype. Not to be confused with a polygenic disorder, which is a phenotype that results from the interaction of multiple genes.
Classification of Hereditary Hearing Impairment
a) Syndromic Hereditary Hearing Impairment
Syndromic are upto 30% of children with hereditary hearing impairment. There are many causative genes for these syndromes which have been identified. These are clinical syndrome. Hearing loss is conductive or mixed.
b) Nonsyndromic Hereditary Hearing Impairment
Almost 2/3rd in numbers. It is almost exclusively caused by mutations of single gene and these hearing impairments are not associated with any other abnormalities.
There are several modes of inheritance of nonsyndromic HHI genes. Several genes have been isolated and cloned. The long list of genes, their loci and location on the chromosomes of autosomal recessive nonsyndromic HHI has been given and will be increasing as the research continues (Ref: Data from Van Camp G, Smith RJH: Hereditary Hearing Loss Homepage.)
The list of syndromes out of few hundred, with inherited, gene, loci and location on chromosomes is prepared (Ref: Data from Van Camp G, Smith RJH: Hereditary Hearing Loss Homepage.)
Hearing Loss Genes and Their Gene Products:
Almost all genes implicated in HHI are identified in last 10 years. These genes encode related proteins which are studied in detail and include:
a) Connexin genes
b) Myosin genes
c) POU genes
d) Ion channel genes
In addition number of genes have been identified (Ref: Data from Van Camp G, Smith RJH: Hereditary Hearing Loss Homepage.)
(a) Connexin genes:
This family is comprised of a group of genes that encode plasma membrane channel proteins of the alpha (A) and beta (B) types.
(b) Myosin genes
This family is related to the super family of myosin genes expressed throughout the body.
(c) The POU genes
Members of POU gene family encode transcription factors, some of which are expressed in the inner and middle ear.
(d) The potassium channel gene super family includes genes that are expressed in the inner ear.
One day genetic testing may be a useful diagnostic tool in the evaluation of Hearing Impairment.
With growing understanding of genetic mutations and their effect on auditory function, scientists hope to develop treatments for many genetic disorders. Researchers explore the possibility of gene therapy for HHI and novel therapies to treat the deficiencies that arise due to genetic mutations. In the future, individuals carrying a genetic mutations responsible for progressive hearing loss may be able to receive a sufficient amount of normal gene product in order to prevent auditory dysfunction.
CLINICAL APPROACH
a) Family History - should be taken in details and should include all under age 30 with hearing problems.
Certain hereditary traits should be inquired into.
b) Physical Examination – to look at the patient as whole, to detect other abnormalities pointing to
syndromes.
c) Audiologic Testing - Cochlear and vestibular testing.
d) Laboratory Testing
d) Radiologic Testing – CT and MR imaging
e) Genetic Testing
-
Christopher J Hartnick, Robin T Cotton
Congenital Laryngeal Anomalies
Otolaryngologic Cl.of North Am. Vol.33(6), Dec.2000, pg.1293-1309
Otolaryngologists face congenital laryngeal anomalies, which may be minor to severe. Such problems present at birth may require immediate attention. He should therefore have firm understanding of these aberrations in embryologic development. This article deals with pertinent embryology, relating to congenital laryngeal anomalies, reviews, the diagnosis and management in details.
Embryology
In 1885, His described the appearance of the respiratory primordium (RP) from an outpouching of the cephalic portion of the pharynx by the third week of gestation.
The following description of the development occurs at different stages of development.
According to Carnegie staging system for human embryologic development, there are two periods of development.
The first period or the embryonic period is 8 weeks and comprises 23 stages.
The second period is Foetal period spans the remaining 32 weeks of gestation.
The larynx begins to develop during stage II (at 25 to 28 days) when RP appears as epithelial thickening on ventral aspect of the foregut.
As the RP develops, outpouch of foregut lumen, the respiratory diverticulum (RD) grows into RP. As the RD develops from primitive pharyngeal floor at the level of adult glottis. The pharyngeal floor is separated from the primitive pharyngeal floor by primitive laryngopharynx which later becomes adult supraglottic region.
Anomalies at this point can result into a number of larynotracheal anomalies.
RD develops and extends inferiorly at stage 13 and 14 and get separated from developing heart and hepatic primordium by the septum transversum (ST).
The esophagus get separated from RD by tracheoesophageal septum. Anomalies of septum transversum leads to bronchobiliary fistula. Arrest of cranial (upward) development of tracheoesophageal septum leads to tracheoesophageal or laryngeal c lefting and tracheoesophageal fistula. Anomalies of the RD itself can cause tracheal agenesis, tracheal stenosis, or complete tracheal rings.
During stage 15 the ventral lumen of primitive laryngopharyngeal region becomes obliterated and gives rise to epithelial lamina (EL). In stage 19 to 23, EL recanalizes, reestablishing the connection between the ventral laryngeal portion and dorsal pharyngoglottic duct.
Failure of recanalization of EL causes spectrum of disorder from laryngeal webs to laryngeal stenosis. With working knowledge, various anomalies can be adhered individually, starting from supraglottis to glottis, subglottis and upper trachea.
LARYNGEAL WEBS
Seventy-five percent webs occur at the level of the glottis. Severity of symptoms will depend on severity of webbing which are classified by Cohen as follows:-
Type I – Anterior web involving 35% of glottis.
– The true vocal cords are visible.
– There is little or no subglottic extension, voice abnormal, slightly hoarseness.
Type II – 35% to 50% glottic involvement.
– Thick anterior webbing with subglottic involvement. Cricoid abnormalities.
– Airway symptoms are uncommon, only during infection or intubation trauma.
– The voice is husky and weak.
Type III – 50% to 70% glottic involved.
– Web thick anteriorly
– True vocal cords invisible
– Cricoid abnormalities
– Marked vocal dysfunction
– Airway symptoms severe and require artificial airway.
Type IV – 75% to 90% glottis involved
– Uniformly thick anterior and posterior
– True cords, not visible
– Subglottis narrowed
– Aphonic
– Airway – immediate help.
Diagnosis is either by flexible laryngoscopy, or by good quality lateral radiograph. It will also demonstrate cricoid abnormality.
Management :
– Type I membranous web observed until the child is 3 to 4 years old and then web divided by a CO2 laser.
– Type II cutting web on each side of the interval of 2 weeks and dilation. Keel placement by endoscopy. Tracheostomy is necessary.
– Type III & IV. Also delayed till 3 to 4 yrs with tracheostomy and later by various reconstructive procedures.
Congenital supraglottic webs are unknown. They could be in anterior part or more rarely in posterior part.
Laryngeal Stenosis and Atresia
It is the most severe form of anomalies. Glottic or supraglottic atresia requires immediate trachneostomy in the labour room and has high mortality ratio. These are also many times associated with host of other anomalies like tracheoesophageal fistula, esophageal atresia, urinary tract abnormalities and limb defects.
Congenital subglottic stenosis is associated with abnormally shaped cricoid cartilage first described by Hollinger in 1954. It is to be differentiated from acquired stenosis, by history only i.e. absence of infection and instrumentation.
When lumen of cricoid is less than 4mm in newborn or less than 3mm in premature, it is congenital subglottic stenosis.
Symptoms will depend on severity of stenosis. Myer-cotton Grading system uses endotracheal tubes to grade.
It is graded in 4 grades –
Grades I – 0-50% obstruction,
Grade II – 51% to 70% obstruction,
Grade III -71% to 99% obstruction
Grade IV – Total obstruction.
Congenital S.G.S. also improves as the larynx grows. Less than 50% require tracheostomy. Dilation has little to offer in cartilaginous stenosis.
In some patients, anterior cricoid split may be necessary to avoid tracheostomy. There are indications worked out by paediatric otolaryngologists:
1. Extubation failure on at least two occasions because of subglottic malformation.
2. Weight greater than 1500g
3. No ventilator support for at least 10 days before procedure
4. Supplemental oxygen requirement less than 30%
5. No congestive heart failure for at least 1 month before the procedure
6. No acute respiratory tract infection
7. No antihypertension medication for at least 10 days before the procedure.
Grade I and Grade II lesion – Role of endoscopic laser treatment and short term stenting exists.
Grade III and Grade IV - Open operative procedure of reconstruction are required.
Laryngeal Clefts
Posterior laryngeal clefts (PLCs) and laryngotracheal esophageal clefts (LTECs) derive from a common embryonic anomaly. 30% of these are associated with polyhydramnios. They are also associated with different syndromes with anomalies of other organs.
Two classifications exists:
A) Evan’s system. – LTEC, type I – supraglottic interaytenoid that extend, above the level of glottis. Cricoid is
uninvolved. Type II - Cricoid and cervical trachea is involved. Type III - Extends to thoracic trachea.
B) Benjamin’s Classification is modified Evans.
Type I - cleft above vocal cord
Type II - partial cricoid cleft and extends to vocal cords
Type III – Total cricoid cleft with or without cervical tracheal cleft.
Type IV - A cleft extending to thoracic trachea with or without involvement of bronchi.
Symptom of Posterior Laryngeal Clefts (PLCs) - copious secretions, aspiration, cyanosis during feeding and recurrent pulmonary infecitons.
Diagnosis : Flexible laryngoscopy
Contrast esophagrams.
Management : Repair of PLCs and LTECs requires control of the airway. Special instrument if any to be done endoscopically or by external operation procedure like laryngofissure or lateral pharyngotomy.
-
Hussam K, EL-Kashlan and Steven A Telian (Univ. of Michigan)
Diagnosis and initiating treatment for peripheral system disorders: Imbalance and Dizziness with Normal hearing
Otolaryng Clinics of N. America, vol.33(3), June 2000
Peripheral vestibular system consists of :
(a) Vestibular labyrinth harbouring neuroepithelium responsible for identifying position and movements of head.
(b) Vestibular nerve (part of cochlear vestibular nerve) carrying nerve fibres from labyrinth to CNS
Disorder of Peripheral systems definitely affects hearing loss along with balance affected. However, certain following conditions cause dizziness without hearing loss.
(1) Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV)
(2) Vestibular neuritis
(3) Recurrent vestibulopathy
(4) Familial vestibulopathy
(5) Bilateral idiopathic vestibulopathy.
Detailed clinical interrogation should include (I) mode of onset and description of first episode. (ii) frequency and duration of each episode (iii) spontaneous or provoking causes (iv) associated auditory causes (v) EAR disease or any surgery on ear in the past.
(1) Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo (BPPV)
It is brief episodes of vertigo precipitated by head movement in certain places. The most common cause, in elderly patients though no identifiable cause is known, commonly follows head trauma sequalea of vestibular neuritis, otologic surgery, infection or prolonged bed rest.
BPPV characteristic clinical feature is that patient experiences giddiness following head movements like getting into or out of bed, rolling over or looking up and is associated with the nystagmus with distinctive characteristics-
a) Latency period following provocative position
b) Intensifies gradually and has crescendo-decrescendo manner.
c) Only 20-30 seconds duration even if position remains same.
d) The nystagmus is torsionally beating towards undermost of the (offending ear) i.e. fast phase towards down ear. It is accompanied by a vertical up or down beating component because of post canal wall and anterior canal wall component respectively.
e) Usually recurs and changes direction when patient moves back to sitting position.
f) The response is fatiguable.
PATHOGENESIS of BPPV
Though there are two theories of mechanisms as to how vertigo occurs, the basic mechanism is accumulation of otoconial debris with higher specific gravity than endolymph within semicircular canal. It responds to linear acceleration including gravitation force.
1) Schuknecht’s cupulithisis theory-
The debris gravitates to adhere to the cupola of semicircular canal and changes in head position stimulates to cause giddiness. The theory, however, cannot explain all classical features of BPPV.
2) Canalithiasis theory by Hall et al and supported by many authors.
This theory postulates clot formation of floating otoconial debris near cupola. A clot moving in ampullofugal direction acts as a plunger on the endolymph, producing pressure or suction in the canal producing deflection of cupola and attack BPPV.
VARIANTS OF BPPV
Any of three semicircular canals may be involved. The direction of nystagmus will depend upon involvement of canal. 91% cases of posterior canal is involved. 3% anterior and 6% of lateral semicircular canals are involved.
– Both vertical canals (i.e. anterior and posterior) produce torsional nystagmus. Vertical component will identify the canal. Upbeating nystagmus will be in a posterior canal, whereas, down beating nystagmus will point towards anterior canal. Provocative movement for vertical canal will be moving from a sitting position to a head hanging position.
– Horizontal canal variant was proposed first by McClure procedures pure horizontal nystagmus and is caused by lateral head turn in supine position. The nystagmus changes direction as the head is turned from one side to the other lateral side. It may be geotropic (fast phase towards dependent ear) or ageotropic (fast phase away from the dependent ear)
– In canalithiasis it is geotropic whereas in cupulothiasis it is ageotropic.
TESTS FOR BPPV
– Hallpike-Dix Test - for vertical canal BPPV
– Side-Lying test – for vertical canal. It is more comfortable and is used in elderly patients.
– Roll-test -f or horizontal canal BPPV.
Treatment
Medical therapy of vestibular suppressants is not effective. In fact, it may affect central habituation process when relieves symptoms.
(a) Single treatment Approach
Aim is to maneuver the debris from canal into vestibule.
The two most commonly used methods are those described by Epley or Semont et al.
(b) Habituation Exercises Approach
In 1980, Brandt and Daroff proposed the exercises which are sequence of lateral head/trunk tilts, repeated many times a day for 2-3 weeks to promote lossening and ultimately, dispersion of the debris towards the utricular cavity. These relieves patients vertigo but difficult to perform by patients because of experience of vertigo during these exercises. This is in sharp contrast to single manuvers of Epley or Semonts procedure.
Surgical Approaches
a) Gacek’s singular neurectomy.
b) Postcanal plugging -procedure of choice by most otologists for BPPV.
(2) Vestibular Neuritis
This is the 3rd most common cause after BPPV and Menier’s.
Clinical features:
i) Sudden onset of vertigo with nausea and vomiting of a few days/
ii) Absent audiologic findings and symptoms or signs.
iii) Absent neurologic symptoms or signs.
iv) Associated mostly with recent or concurrent URI (upper respiratory infection)
v) Reduced or absent caloric response in one ear.
vi) URIs – therefore can be seen in epidemics.
vii) Autopsy reports axonal degeneration of one or more vestibular trunk points towards virus.
Acute vertigo and spontaneous nystagmus which lasts a few days improves gradually though during recovery period any moment may provoke dizziness. Improvement is seen because (a) recovery of labyrinthine function (b) central compensation by adaptation though vestibular weakness can be demonstrated on one side. In elderly, it lasts longer.
– BPPV has been reported following some vestibular neuritis patients.
– Vestibular neuritis is single episode but some patient’s recurrent episodes may occur. Sequential vestibular neuritis in both ears may lead to differential diagnosis of bilateral vestibular neuritis.
During investigations - vestibular neuritis showed reduced partial vestibular response in 90% of patients upto one month and 80% after 6 months. 42% patients showed recovery to normal caloric response in 10 year follow up study.
– Peculiarly superior division of vestibular neuritis trunk is commonly affected. This supplies horizontal and anterior semicircular canals, maculae of the utricle and anterosuperior part of saculae. Inferior division supplying posterior semicircular canal is spared.
This is corroborated by findings of temporal bone pathology and analysis of 3-dimensional properties of vestibulo occular nystagmus, in patients with vestibular neuritis.
Differential Diagnosis:-
– Cerebellar infarction
– Wallenberg’s syndrome
– Meniere’s disease
– Acoustic neuromas
– Migraine equivalent vertigo,
– Paraneoplastic syndrome,
– Metastatic carcinoma
– Multiple sclerosis.
Treatment : Symptomatic and supportive. Acute phase treated by labyrinthine sedatives and antiemetics. Possibly good effects of corticosteroids.
Antiviral – No response
Most of them have complete recovery. Those with persistent unsteadiness, have to undergo customised vestibular rehabilitation programme.
(3) Bilateral Idiopathic Vestibulopathy
Bilateral loss of vestibular function is induced most commonly by vestibuloxic effects of aminoglycosides gentamycin. This often has hearing loss in higher frequencies. Majority have no hearing loss but bilateral vestibular weakness. 20% with bilateral vestibulo hypofunction have no identifiable cause.
Patterns of symptoms – 2 patterns are seen
(i) present with initial vertigo
(ii) present with insidius progressive unsteadiness without vertigo.
Patients complain dysequilibrium which is worse at night and also accompanied by oscillopsia. This is caused by loss of bilateral vestibulo-ocular reflex {VOR}. Clinically this is tested by making patient to read a Snellen’s chart with steady head and then during horizontal head oscillations at a frequency of about 2Hz. Normal vestibular response show a one-line deterioration in visual acuity and with bilateral vestibular involvement. Five line deterioration is seen.
Testing is by bilateral thermal caloric responses and rotational chair testing.
Management of patients with bilateral vestibular loss is difficult. 50% show some improvement with adaptable exercise. Emphasis is placed on maximizing and optimizing visual and proprioceptive sensory inputs to substitute for the lost vestibular inputs. Risk of drowning is seen.
FAMILIAL VESTIBULOPATHY –
Described by Baloh et al in 1994 and is presumed to have autosomal dominant mode of inheritance. It is characterised by brief episodes of vertigo for several years. Subsequently, it results in chronic dysequilibrium and oscillopsia. Bilateral vestibular weakness and response on caloric testing, electronystagmography vestibulo ocular reflex reduced. Gain on rotation chair testing.
All tests were normal, audiologic, imaging and neurological findings. Migraine headaches were an important feature of this syndrome. All members and their parents suffer from migraine.
Treatment : All patients responded well to treatment with acetazolamide with resolution of attack of vertigo. The location of site of lesion is unknonwn.
Another familial syndrome with episodes of little longer lasting vertigo and essential treatment migraine has been identified. No progressive bilateral vestibular weakness develops. Acetazolamide was helpful in reducing vertigo and migraine.
RECURRENT VESTIBULOPATHY
This clinical entity was described by LeLiever and Barber in 1981. Recurrent spontaneous episodes of vertigo similar to that of Meniere’s disease. However, no audiologic, neurologic symptoms and signs noted. The natural history is different from that of Menieres. 73 patients followed up for 8.5 yrs, 72% retained original diagnosis, however the diagnosis was changed to Meniere’s disease in 14% and 8% in BPPV.
There is no known cause. Viral cause has been suggested. Periodic blockade of afferent activity of one vestibular nerve by reactivation of dominant virus is postulated as a mechanism. 22% patients showed reduced unilateral caloric response.
Treatment: Symptomatic and assurance. The prognosis for spontaneous resolution is good.
-
David Solomon
Distinguishing and Treating Causes of Central Vertigo
Otolaryn Cl.of North Americal, vol.33(3), June 2000, pg. 579-
When evaluating a case of acute vertigo, it is important to make sure to distinguish between peripheral and central cause. Central causes require urgent intervention or may require intensive care unit (ICU) monitoring.
How history, examination and laboratory testing can help to confirm a central etiology is considered.
History – patient feel “woozy”, “about to black out,” “disoriented” or “lightheadedness”. Worse while standing. These are connected with blood flow circulation to brain, therefore central.
Causes : 1) Hyperventilation
2) Orthostatic hypotension
3) Vasovagal attacks
4) Cause of decreased cardiac output
5) Psychophysiologic
6) Hypoglycemic
7) Drug toxicities – like alcohol, barbiturates, benzodiazepine and
anticonvulsants.
8) Postconcussion syndrome
9) Infarction of labyrinth, brainstem or cerebellum
10) Migraine headache.
Examination and testing
a) complete neurologic examination
b) study of nystagmus and its induction test.
Absence of a positive head impulse test in acute vertigo attack makes a central cause.
Bedside examination findings suggestive of nonperipheral etiology.
Position Provoked Vertigo –
Brainstem and cerebellar lesion can cause persistent vertigo with vertical nystagmus or torsional nystagmus.
1. Direction changing or purely vertical nystagmus
2. Sustained or nonfatiguing positional nystagmus
3. Dissociated (disconjugate) nystagmus
4. Abnormal posture when seated, inability to stand
5. Focal motor deficit
6. Dysarthria, dysphagia, diplopia, dysmetrial (limb ataxia)
7. Horner’s syndrome (sympathetic paresis of the pupil, with unilateral failure to dilate in darkness and ptosis)
8. Loss of pin prick or temperature sensation on one side of the face, or on the other side of the body.
9. Intractable hiccups.
Ocular Motor Signs of Central Disease
Persistent vertical nystagmus is certainly of central origin. It indicates brainstem involvement as well as diffuse cerebellar region.
Diagnoses in Patients with Downbeat Nystagmus
Infarction 25%
Cerebellar (spinocerebellar) degeneration 24%
Multiple sclerosis 13%
Developmental anomaly (e.g. Chiari, basilar invagination) 12%
Drug toxicity (phenytoin, carbamazepine) 4%
Trauma 3%
Neoplasm 3%
Alcoholic cerebellar degeneration 2%
Arteriovenous malformation 2%
AIDS, familial periodic ataxia, viral encephalitis, radiation 1% (each)
No cause 5%.
– Disconjugate recordings are indicative of lesions of the medical longitudinal fasciculus.
– Perverted nystagmus is related to lesion of vestibular nuclei
– Sea-saw nystagmus – cuased by midline compressive lesions in suprasellar area in which it is generally pendular.
– Unilateral lesions in the rostral midbrain cause a jerk waveform see-saw nystagmus.
– Vertical diplopia – sign of supranuclear or infranuclear pathology.
– Periodic alternating nystagmus occur with lesion of posterior cerebellar vermis.
Characteristics of Central Nystagmus:
Central spontaneous nystagmus is direction changing pure vertical, or torsion, is not suppressed by vision and is associated with normal head impulse test and ataxia even for sitting patients cannot stand.
Cerebellar signs:
Whatever may be the aetiology, signs are as follows:
1. Gaze-evoked, direction-changing horizontal nystagmus
2. Rebound nystagmus
3. Vertical, typically downbeat nystagmus, often worse in lateral gaze.
4. Alternating skew deviation
5. Saccadic dysmetria and major saccadic oscillations (flutte,r macrosquare-wave jerks)
6. Position-provoked vertigo (not fitting benign paroxysmal positional vertigo)
7. Oscillopsia at rest (caused by nystagmus) and head movement.
8. Wide-based gait ataxia with poor tandem gait, inability to maintain Romberg position even with eyes open
9. Poor horizontal and vertical smooth pursuit (absent VOR cancellation)
10. Tremor, dysarthria, limb ataxia.
Spinocerebellar atrophy
Migraine
Multiple sclerosis
Internuclear ophthalmoplegia
Vascular disease
Lateral Medullary Syndrome
Positive syndrome
Cerebellar infarction.
Vascular malformtion and headache
Neoplastic disease
Other conditions – Palatal tremor
– Wernicke’s encephalopathy
– Epilepsy
All the above conditions are central cause of nystagmus.
-
NH Blevins, BL Carter (Tufts-New England Med Ctr, Boston)
Clinical Forum: Routine Preoperative Imaging in Chronic Ear Surgery,
Am J Otol 19: 527-538, 1998.
Imaging studies, especially CT, can demonstrate the nature and extent of chronic otitis media, which may not be apparent on clinical findings per se. Such findings can affect operative treatment, especially in difficult and/or revision procedures. However, there is a view that routine radiography of the mastoid may suffice in being very helpful in most cases.
-
TS Karhuketo, HJ Puhakka (Tampere Univ, Findland)
Middle Ear Imaging Via the Eustachian Tube With a Superfine Fiberoptic Videomicroendoscope.
ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec. 60: 30-34, 1998.
With a fibreoptic videomicroendoscope inserted through the Eustachian tube, 56% of predetermined anatomical objects in the middle ear were visualized.
However, one may find obstructive sites or mucosal folds that may prevent a complete view of all the contents of the middle ear cleft.
-
Michael J Ruckenstein, (Univ of Pennsylvania)
Vertigo & Dysequilibrium with Associated Hearing Loss
Otolaryng. Cl.of N.America, June 2000. Vol.33(3), pg.535-562
CONGENITAL
Congenital malformations of the membranous or osseomembranous components of the inner ear results from defects in inner ear development during the fourth to eighth week of fetal gestation.
The overall incidence of congenital is 1 in 1000 live births. It is either syndromic or nonsyndromic presentation.
Clinical presentation is with hearing loss which is either congenital or within two decades of life. Only 20% complained of vertigo or imbalance.
CT Scan on MRI of high resolution reveal the abnormalities. Abnormal vestibular findings are recorded on vestibular testing.
CLASSIFICATION OF CONGENITAL LABYRINTHINE ANOMALIES
Malformations of the membranous labyrinth
Complete membranous dysplasia
Partial membranous dysplasia
Cochleosaccular (Scheibe)
Cochlea – basal turn (Alexander)
Malformations of the osseous and membranous labyrinth
Complete labyrinthine aplasia (Michel)
Cochlear
Aplasia
Hypoplasia
Incomplete partition (Mondini)
Common cavity
Labyrinthine
Dysplasia of the semicircular canals
Aplasia of the semicircular canals.
Malformations of the vestibular aqueduct
Narrow or wide internal auditory canal.
Treatment:
Hearing amplification with hearing aids or cochlear implants are the mainstay of treatment. Vestibular suppressant medication are indicated for bouts of vertigo if any.
ACQUIRED
Trauma – Temporal Bone
Blunt trauma or penetrating trauma. Auto accidents or bullet or knife injuries to inner ear damage results into sensorineural hearing loss. Facial nerve may be damaged.
Clinical presentation:
Vertigo and hearing loss or facial nerve paralysis, bleeding from ear or watery fluid (Cerebrospinal fluid – CSF) from the ear. CT Scan may reveal fracture line in temporal bone.
Treatment will depend upon the presentation and investigative findings. Exploration of ear and mastoid of facial nerve or CSF leak is present or conductive hearing loss is present.
Barotrauma
Rapid changes in ambient pressure may result in pressure transmitted to inner ear, thus causing temporary or permanent inner ear dysfunction.
Aetiological factors are seen in drivers, airplane flight or forceful sneezing or airblast injuries. Treatment will depend upon the aetiological factors.
Perilymph Fistula
Three possible mechanisms:
(a) Congenital dehiscences in labyrinth
(b) Disruption of oval or round windows by secondary to trauma which may be iatrogenic, (poststapedectomy) or penetrating or severe implosive pressure trauma. Even barotrauma may cause the fistula.
(c) Spontaneous – controversial
Clinically – present with sudden sensorinueral loss associated with tinnitus and vertigo. Fluctuating hearing loss.
Investigations: No valid or accurate diagnostic tests. Audioventricular testing is done.
Present – Exploration of middle ear and locating the leak and sealing it
Otosclerosis
Usually conductive hearing loss and the diagnosis is easy by audiological testing. Clinically young adults with tinnitus and conductive hearing loss. Family history may suggest otosclerosis.
Usually no vestibular complaints. If at all any, then they complain of vertigo. Three possible patterns are noted. Positional vertigo or Meniere’s like syndrome or small number manifest as recurrent episodes of vertigo.
Treatment :
It is by stapedectomy. Small number with sensorineural loss or mixed loss are treated with fluoride.
Neoplasm:
Cerebellopontine angle tumours, vestibular schwannoma, meningioma or petrous apex cholesteatomas.
Clinically present with vertigo, hearing loss, tinnitus or facial nerve paryngitis. Very large tumours may demonstrte 5th, 9th, 10th or 11th with cerebellar signs.
Diagnosis : By CT scan or MRI
Treatment : It is operative treatment.
Infectious:
Labyrinthins: Either by bacteria or virus, depending upon otitis media or general viral infection. Herpes infection.
Clinical presentation is by sudden severe hearing sensorineural hearing loss, with vertigo lasting for days. Hearing may be irreversibly damaged.
Treatment will be by antibiotics and corticosteroid. Operative treatment for those with cholesteatoma or chronic mastiditis.
Syphilis:
Is rare nowadays. It is diagnosed by VDRL. FTA - ABS or MHA – TP tests are done to confirm. Treatment is by antibiotics and steroids.
Ototoxicity
Most agents are toxic to cochlea. Aminoglycoside antibiotics are major vestibulotoxic drugs used today. Individual succeptibility, in addition to renal failure, hepatic failure or old age, concurrent use of other ototoxic drugs, familial history are other aetiological factors.
The most common are Gentamycin and streptomycin and tobramycin. Outer hair cells of the vestibule is affected mainly. The basal regions of cochlea, the apices of the cristae, and the striolar regions of the maculae are affected most.
Clinically – acute onset of hearing loss or imablance with oscillopsia is seen. These occurs while patient is on treatment or up to several weeks after treatment. Usually bilaterally affected. Vestibular damage is permanent. Bilateral vestibular reduced response is seen on caloric testing or ENG.
Treatment is mainly by monitoring the effects of drug to prevent. Once it occurs then only symptomatic treatment is given.
Immunologic:
Autoimmune Inner Ear Disease
Patients own immune system becomes reactive to self-antigens resulting into autoimmune disease. Multisystemic autoimmune disease like systemic lupus erythematosus may be associated.
It is rare cause. Degeneration of organ of Corti, vestibular sensory organs, stria vascularis and dark cell layers, as well as fibrosis and osteoneogenesis is seen.
Clinical Presentation :
Rapidly progressive bilateral asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss is seen. Hearing levels fluctuates and 25-50% patients complain of vertigo.
Cogan’s syndrome :
Patients present with interstitial keratitis with vertigo, hearing loss and tinnitus. Ocular and labyrinthine pathology occur together or within 6 months of each other.
Other Multisystemic Autoimmune Diseases:
Wegner’s granulomatosis, polyartertitis nodosa, rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, sarcoidosis and ulcerative colitis may involve the inner ear.
Investigations are mainly various antigen antibody tests but are not very helpful. Only probable diagnosis is proved by positive response to imunosuppressant drugs like corticosteroids.
Dose is 1 to 2mg/kg/day for 1 month. Other drugs are methotrexate or cyclophosphamide. The maintenance of the dosages are required.
IDIOPATHIC
Meniere’s disease
Symptom complex of vertigo,hearing loss, tinnitus and aural fullness. Pathology is endolymphatic hydrops.
Clinically it presents as episodic vertigo associated with fluctuating and progressive hearing loss, chronic tinnitus and fullness of ears.
Investigations – audiometric test
ECOG
FTA-AB – serological test
Treatment – Medical – vestibular suppressants
– diuretics
– vasodilatation
Surgical – Endolymphatic sac surgery procedure
Gentamycin perfusion
Vestibular nerve section
Labyrinthectomy.
-
Craig S, Derkay, MD, and David H. Darrow, MD
Voice Disorders and Phonosurgery II
From the Department of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery, Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk, Virginia
The Otolaryngologic Clinics of North America Volume 33, Number 5, Ocober 2000, Pg. 1127
Recurrent respiratory papillomatosis [RRP] is a disease of viral origin, caused by human papillomavirus.
Although it is a benign disease, RRP has potentially morbidconsequences because of its involvement of the airway and the risk of malignant conversion.
Recurrent respiratory papillomatosis is the most common benign neoplasm of the larynx among children and is the second most frequent cause of childhood hoarseness.
Although is usually involves the larynx, RRP may involve the entire aerodigestive tract.
Because the most common symptoms of RRP are related to airway obstruction, it is not uncommon for children to be misdiagnosed initially as having asthma, croup, or chronic bronchitis.
The hallmark of RRP in children is the triad of relentlessly progressive hoarseness, stridor, and respiratory distress.
ORIGIN
Human Papillomavirus
Until the 1990s, HPV had been suspected but not confirmed as the causative agent in RRP.
This uncertainty developed from an inability to culture the virus in vitro, and from the failure to demonstrate viral particles consistently in papilloma lesions using electron microscopy of HPV antibodies.
With the use of viral probes, HPV DNA has been identified in almost every papilloma lesion studied.
The most common types identified in the airway are HPV 6 and HPV 11, the same types responsible for genital warts.
An association between cervical HPV infection in the mother and the incidence of RRP has been well established.
Adult-onset respiratory papillomas could reflect either activation of virus present since birth or an infection acquired in adolescence or adult life.
Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis
The most common sits for RRP are the limen vestibuli, the nasopharyngeal surface of the soft palate, the midline of the laryngeal surface of the epiglottis, the upper and lower margins of the ventricle, the undersurface of the vocal folds, the carina, and at bronchial spurs.
Surgical Management
No single modality has consistently been shown to be effective in eradicating RRP.
The CO2 laser has been favored over cold instruments in the treatment of RRP involving the larynx, pharynx, upper trachea, and nasal and oral cavities.
Although the CO laser allows surgical precision and excellent hemostasis, multiple procedures are often necessary.
Because currently no therapeutic regimen reliably eradicates the HPV, when there is a question about whether papilloma in an area needs to be removed, it is prudent to accept some residual papilloma rather than risk damage to normal tissue and producing excessive scarring.
Even with the removal of all clinically evident papilloma, latent virus may remain in adjacent tissue; this remaining latent virus may explain the recurrent nature of RRP.
Adjuvant Treatment Modalities
The most commonly recommended adjuvant therapy is alpha-interferon. The exact mechanism by which alpha-interferon elicits its response is unknown.
Common interferon side effects fall into two categories: acute reactions [fever and generalized flu-like symptoms, chills, headache, myalgias, and nausea that seem to decrease with prolonged therapy] and chronic reactions [decrease in the growth rate of the child, elevation of liver transaminase levels, leukopenia spastic diplegia, and febrile seizures.
Acetaminophen has been found to relive the fevers effectively, and interferon injections are best tolerated at bedtime.
Photodynamic therapy [PDT] in the treatment of RRP has been studied extensively:-
Photodynamic therapy is based on the transfer of energy to a photosensitive drug. The drug originally used was dihematoporphyrin ether [DHE], which has a tendency to concentrate within papillomas more than in surrounding normal tissue.
Ribavirin is an antiviral drug, used to treat respiratory syncytial virus pneumonia in infants, that has also shown some promise in the treatment of aggressive laryngeal papillomatosis.
Another antiviral drug that has been advocated in the treatment of RRP is acyclovir.
It has been postulated that acyclovir may be most effective when there are comorbidities, such as a simultaneous infection with herpes simples virus.
Two recent reports have stimulated interest in the intralesional injection of cidofovir [Vistide ] [HPMPC], a drug currently FDA-approved for use for HIV patients with CMV retinitis.
-
P. Chang, Los Angeles, USA.
Controversies in Vestibular Schwannoma Treatment: Surgery versus Irradiation.
ENT News, 9(5), Nov./Dec.2000, p.14-15
Cropping of these controversies has been because of irradiation as an alternative to surgery. Microsurgery is the present day choice for vestibular schwannoma.
The following questions arise in the critical minds of patients:
a) What is the expected morbidity of surgery?
b) Is hearing preservation possible?
c) Can benign tumour be irradiated without any long-term side effects?
d) How effective radiation is?
e) Are the results competitive to that of surgery. Will all be judged in justifying the alternative treatment of Vestibular Schwannoma?
Tumour:
Vestibular schwannoma tumours arise from neural sheaths and are benign. Their situation in internal auditory canal and cerebellopontine angle, make them dangerous by position. The tumour consists of nothing but proliferating Schwann cells, which is very slow viz. 1 to 2 mm per year. Majority grows producing progressive hearing loss. This growth however, exceptionally can be unpredictable. That is why in fit patient, intervention is required. Technological advances in early precise diagnosis by imaging techniques and advances in management have proved the surgical outcomes much favourable.
However, technological advances in radiotherapy have also offered an alternative treatment.
Surgical Background:
It has come a long way from removal of tumour by finger, by Balance in London in 1894 to perfection of precise removal by translabyrinthine, retrosigmoid and middle fossa approaches derived by Dr. William House in 1964, almost without mortality and minimal of morbidity. Today there is likelihood of complete removal with zero mortality rate, near normal facial nerve function in 95% and less than 0.3% recurrence rate and 70% rate of preservation of hearing in selected patient makes the treatment by surgical excision treatment of choice.
The negative points are that it is intracranial procedure with its attendant risks of C.S.F leak, meningitis and intracranial bleed. It incurs cost and 4-5 days of hospitalization.
Today the treatment by radiation may be opted to (a) Medically unfit patients (b) Recurrent tumours (c) Elderly patients (d) Who refuse surgery. The use of radiotherapy as primary mode of treatment of vestibular schwannoma has also been promoted.
Background of Radiotherapy
Lars Leksell (1971) at Sweden (Karolinska Institute in Stockholm) first reported gamma radiation ports administered stereotactically during a single sitting to arrest the tumour growth.
The principle is to target the lesion, minimising, the radiation dose to surrounding neural tissues. The term “stereotactic radiosurgery” was coined and particular technique used was called the ‘gamma knife’.
The treatment evolved in last decades. The radiation dosage of 25Gy has been reduced optimally to 13Gy delivered by Linear accelerator and is now fractionate. This has resulted into improvement in tumour control and preservation of normal neural tissue.
The Controversy
– Because of close relations of tumour capsule to 7th and 8th nerve, it is impossible to avoid radiation to these nerves.
– The effects of radiation are cell deaths and delayed vasculitis. Vasculitis is not observed because of sparse blood supply as against seen in glomus.
– Subsequent surgical intervention, if required in these irradiated tumour, lead to hazzardous dissection resulting in poor hearing and facial nerve function.
So the alternative treatment is reserved for those patients who are unfit or unwilling to undergo microsurgical removal of tumour.
-
John Diaz Day, (Neurological and Skull Base Surgeon, House Ear Clinic, Los Angeles, USA)
Radiotherapy or microsurgery – which treatment and why?
ENT News, vol.9(5),Nov/Dec.2000, p.16-17
The microsurgical excisions are currently exceeded and continue to improve.
If the results are compared with those centres with inexperienced teams doing small number of cases, the stereotactic radiotherapy gains momentum.
Patients with tumours 3cm or larger most agree are candidates for surgery. Relief of mass effect and hydrocephalus is well achieved. Facial nerve function and hearing preservation in anyway par with large tumours. The extent of 60% in facial nerve function preservation is good.
Main debate over patients with small or medium tumours, intracanalicular tumours tilt in favour of surgery for number of reasons.
At this institution in 372 patients over the last 5 yrs had 95% of facial nerve function preservation and about 70% hearing preservation was seen. These results of function preservation are durable. This is not so in stereotactic radiosurgery where hearing may further deteriorate with time.
Recurrent rate in surgery is 0.5% as against radiation which is 6-10%, where the tumor recurs or grows further.
He also points out that if radiation fails subsequent microdissection results in poor function of facial nerve preservation and hearing preservation.
Radiosurgical series still must stand the test of time when utilizing ‘control’ as a means of establishing efficacy. They must do better than the natural history of vestibular schwannomas left untreated. When roughly two-thirds of tumours will not change their appearance on serial imaging with no treatment, how do we can say that my treatment is effective at ‘controlling’ tumour growth over a similar follow-up period with a similar number of tumours not demonstrating growth ?
-
Andras A Kemeny, Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield, England
What is the role of radiosurgery in Vestibular Schwannoma treatment?
ENT News, Nov/Dec.2000, vol.9(5), p.19
It is a surgical technique, the concentrated radiation is achieved by crossfiring 201 fine gamma ray beams focused into a single point. Initially with poor imaging and slow computers, this was difficult to achieve. But with the introduction of high resolution, volume acquisition MR imaging and powerful 3D computational software the true potential of this technique could be realised.
Since 1985, 540 accoustic neuromas were treated with mean age 51, 48% males, 21% (116) were bilateral tumours. The median diameter was 6-57mm. 36% had at atleast one previous resectional surgery. A large proportional had neurological deficit particularly with those who had surgical intervention. Even since 1995, only 20% have normal facial nerve function and 13% had none. Seventy-two cases of previously operated cases had complete deafness.
In 1980, when 25Gy dose was given, facial weakness in 85% and hearing preservation was poor. With reduction of dose to 13-15Gy, radiological tumour control remained around 88% with minimum follow-up of 5 years. Useful hearing was preserved in 76% and facial weakness only in 5.2%. These results compare well with larger surgical series.
Radiosurgical failures are not declared for at least 3 yrs and no surgery should be undertaken on this basis.
The risks and difficulty of surgery after radiosurgery is exaggerated.
A warning by nonpractising radiosurgeons is given to patietns of possibility of malignant change in later years. Very rarely seen. To date about 15000 acoustic neuromas are treated and by telephone survey, only 5 cases of sarcomatous change were confirmed after radiosurgery. Nevertheless, the alertness is necessary.
Which cases should be referred to radiosurgery? Probably the answer is which should not be?
Lesions beyond 3.5cm that produce larger mass effect may need surgical decompression. Tumours incidentally found may be monitored radiologically and audiometrically.
Those above 65 years of age, the medically infirm and those who can’t afford even a low risk of surgical mortality will be more and more considered for radiosurgery.
There is a demand for noninvasive methods of treatment with less disruption to their life. Those who are well informed by internet and those who are in medicolegal climate should be informed of availability of radiosurgery of these tumours.
-
Dr. Paul A Fagan, St. Vincent’s Hospital, Sydney, Australia
How does the outcome of radiotherapy compare with microsurgery for vestibular schwannomas?
ENT News, Nov./Dec.2000. vol.9(5), p.20
The article discusses pros and cons of both treatment but tilts more in tumour of surgery.
In summary, the author states surgery for acoustic neuroma is a proven, safe and effective treatment with reproducible results. In particular, the long-term safety of this treatment is well documented. Radiotherapy, on the other hand, does not achieve a cure, the early results are little different to the natural history of the disease and serious long-term complications can occur.
-
L Dade Lunsford, Ajay Niranjan, (Pittsburg, Philadelphia)
What are the results and rationale of stereotactic radiotherapy in the management of vestibular schwannomas?
ENT News, Vol.9(5), Nov./Dec.2000. P.23
For acoustic neuromas, the surgical alternatives are microsurgery and gamma knife.
Today, good imaging technique achievers have very early diagnosis with minimal symptoms. The goals of management have shifted from tumour removal to preservation of neurological function viz. facial nerve function and hearing preservation.
The goals of radiosurgery are to inactivate the tumour, as against physical removal by microsurgery. The gradual tumour reduction in size is noted over the next two to seven years period. The aim is to prevent further growth, while preserving 7th and 8th nerve function and other neurological and employment status.
At the University of Pittsburgh, 622 patients have undergone gamma knife radiosurgery over a period of 13 years.
Currently, 13Gy to the tumour margin in a single session is utilized. Usually within 6-18 hours patient is discharged. All patients are followed up with MRI and audiometric studies at 6-months, 1,2,4 and 8 years.
Analysis of 5-10 year outcome of 162 unilateral tumours treated with radiosurgery between 1987 and 1992, a 98% tumour control rate has been achieved. Only 2% of patients required tumour resection. No additional difficulties were encountered in resection procedure.
No patient with an intracanalicular tumour developed new facial or trigeminal neuropathies, 21 of 487 patients (4.3%) had improvement in hearing.
With all patients, the concept of tumour growth control versus tumour removal should be discussed. All options should be put forward. According to him by 2001, many patients with newly diagnosed acoustic tumours should undergo gamma knife radiosurgery as the management option of choice.
-
Som PM, Curtin HD, Mancuso AA
Imaging of the Neck
ORL 2000; 62: 186-198
This article relates to the use of C-T scanning in staging of neck in details. A full written classification is given in the text together with diagnosis explaining each of the levels. It is very clear and consistent set of guidelines to help stage the neck on radiological grounds - CJW.
-
Kau R J, Alexiou C, Stimmer H, Arnold W.
Investigations for neck nodes
ORL, 2000; 62: 199-203
This well-written article from Germany provides an overview of the current methods used in status of neck nodes in head and neck malignancies. It compares CT, MRI, ultrasound (US), US guided FNAC, colour doppler US and PET with clinical staging.
The least accurate method of detecting lymph node, though the cheapest method of palpation gives 69.7% accuracy. Ultrasound with its limitation of 72.7%, and US guided FNAC 89%.¸CT has 84.9%, MRI 85%. PET scanning most accurate at 90.5% but is not easily available. Colour doppler studies -show reactive nodes have increased hilar blood flow, while metastatic nodes have peripheral blood flow.
The advantage of US guided FNAC is that it gives histological diagnosis and staging. However, its invasive procedure is to be kept in mind.
-
Fertilo A, Som PM, Rinaldo A, Mondin V
Classification of neck dissection
ORL -2000; 62: 212-216
Many terms are used in various neck dissection procedures but to describe accurately what procedure has been done is still confusing.
The most commonly accepted classifications designed by Fertilo in 1998. This divides into (1) comprehensive neck dissection (2) selective neck dissection and (3) extended neck dissection.
1. Comprehensive neck dissection – (including radical or modified radical) involves dissection of I-V level.
2. Selective neck dissection
In this one or more lymph node levels are left in situ.
3. Extended neck dissection – it implies removal of all I-V level nodes and additional lymph nodes or structures, which are not removed in radical neck. Additional structures include accessory nerve, jugular vein, or sternocleidomastoid muscle.
The authors suggest the staging of the neck by P M Som to be methodology and then described the surgical procedures in the above manner i.e. level of lymph nodes and additional structures removed or preserved. This is simple method to record and compare.
-
Fertilo A, Silver CE, Rinaldo A, Smith RV
Surgical options for the neck
ORL 2000: 62: 217-225.
This article summarises the surgical options for both NO and node positive necks. It also discusses the adjuvant treatment of radiotherapy or chemotherapy.
(A) In clinical and radiological negative neck – selective lateral neck dissection with levels II to IV or VI as necessary with or without preservation of 11th, Jugular vein or sternocleidomastoid.
(B) In the necks – treatment varies on N stage.
(a) High N stage neck – Radical neck dissection including VI and VII where necessary.
(b) However, N stage neck – more selective neck dissections after levels I to V including VI or VII.
Postoperative adjuvant therapy are best reserved for extracapsular spread. Authors prefer primary surgery as it allows accurate p-staging with obvious prognostic implications. CJW.
-
Ferjaoui M, Kooli H, Najeh D, Hajri H
The nose in Crohn’s disease
Revue De Laryngologie Otologie Rhinologie, 1999: 5: 341-342
This is a case report of very aggressive type of primary atrophic rhinitis. With marked crustastions, destruction of the turbinates and septum with saddling of nose and involvement of maxillary sinus.
The second biopsy done during (intestinal exacerbation) showed typical features of Crohn’s disease.
The systemic therapy of intestinal disease improved all nasal pathology.
The issue is to ask, patients of Primary Atrophic Rhinitis, about gastrointestinal symptoms and other lesions suggestive of Crohn’s disease.
-
Krouse JH
Staging of Inverted Papilloma
Laryngoscope 2000: 110: 965-968
Formerly medical maxillectomy through an external incision was treatment of choice as against that today endoscopy is the treatment followed by most of them. This is controversial because of an association of inverted papilloma with malignancy.
This study utilized a literature review to develop a simple and easily applied staging system – based on endoscopic examination of the nasal cavity and CT scanning.
The staging system is as follows:-
Stage I – Disease is limited to nasal cavity.
Stage II – It is limited to the ethmoid sinuses and medial and superior portion of the
maxillary sinuses.
Stage III – Involves the lateral or inferior aspects of maxillary sinuses or extension
into the frontal or sphenoid sinuses.
Stage IV – Involves tumour spread outside the confines of the nose.
-
Moreau PR
Laser Laryngeal Surgery